08/16/2026
This is the letter that was read at all masses this weekend regarding the St. Stephen Church building. Please continue to pray for our church leaders as this has been a very difficult decision and has taken a lot of time, prayer and patience.
Sunday, August 16, 2026
Twentieth Sunday in Ordinary Time
Dear St. Joseph Parish family,
As we are with Jesus in these stormy and difficult times for our parish and community, please let me encourage all of us to keep our eyes fixed on our LORD and God and continue to pray like St. Peter, “LORD, save me.” This is also the prayer of this courageous woman of faith in the Gospel today. Jesus has continued to reach out His saving hand to me these days, and He will do so for all of us if we let Him. This, for sure, continues to require of us a deep faith and trust in our loving God and in His generous care for all of us.
This is another poignant reminder to all of us that our Church is truly the people of God and the Body of Christ that gather, independent of the building we gather in. We are called to have the faith of the people of Israel who first gathered to worship God present in the Ark of the Covenant in a meeting tent that moved with them on pilgrimage to the Promised Land from place to place. We are also called to be united in charity like the first Christians of the Acts of the Apostles who had no stable church buildings but gathered on the LORD’s Day in different houses. Yes, our sacred buildings are a tremendous blessing and a gift, but the building alone is not the Church. We are all reminded in these days the Truth of the Scriptures, “For here we have no lasting city, but we seek the City which is to come.” (Hebrews 13:14)
I need to make this very difficult announcement today that it has been decided by me, your pastor, our parish leadership, and our Bishop and Diocese that the St. Stephen Church building will be torn down and the lot cleared for a hopeful future sale of the vacant lot. This past Monday both our Pastoral and Finance Councils met and after some very ardent prayer and emotional discussion members of both councils unanimously counseled me and consented to this decision to tear down the St. Stephen’s Church building. Both councils also unanimously consented to taking a loan from the Diocese to cover the cost of the demolition which will be repaid in large part with the hopeful sale of the lot.
I hope you all know that every one of us from the Bishop, our council members, and myself have not taken this decision lightly. It has burdened us all, and, speaking for myself, has filled me with much heartache and sadness. Even through the heartache and sadness though I am confident that this is the correct decision that will allow our parish and community to really heal and, please God, after the time of mourning and grief, truly come together as one Catholic community of faith, hope, and love here in Oil City at St. Joseph Parish.
So many have expressed the sentiment that this church is where I was baptized or where I received my first Holy Communion, or where I was married. Praise God for these sacred moments and these holy memories. This cannot and will not ever take these moments and memories away. We now encounter God, worship Him, and receive His abundant love and mercy in this building, and more importantly, this community of faith which is now called to come together even more.
The timeline for the demolition and clearing of the land is still being finalized, but it will be within the next four to eight weeks. In the meantime, the parish is working quickly and safely to remove and preserve all the sacred patrimony that we can from St. Stephen Church such as the stained-glass windows and statues. Although it is very hard for me to go through this with you, I am truly blessed to be with you through this as your spiritual father and your pastor. As I said in my last letter, I do encourage you to please refrain from receiving and contributing to all of the often negative, unkind, and caustic commentary on Facebook and social media. Please reach out to me, Fr. Festus, Deacon Kevin, and to your brothers and sisters in our parish to mourn with, to support each other, and, most importantly to pray with.
Again, I hope you know how much I love and care for you all! I am there with you in the boat praying for the grace to remain focused on Jesus with my eyes, heart, and soul fixed on Him. I pray that in these coming days and weeks the LORD may say of us what he said about the courageous woman of the Gospel today, “Great is your faith!”
Yours always in Christ’s peace,
Fr. Dan Hoffman
Pastor