03/23/2021
SPLITTING THE CHURCH
The reason for a church split is always associated with sin. Splitting is usually done by deception, gossip, slander, rebellion, pride, jealousy, strife, and other evil acts. A church split happens when someone seeks to manipulate people or events for his own ends.
Why would such happen in any church? What would lead to this? There are symptoms in the church for months before it happens. What is the root cause of a church split? Usually, a disagreement about something that may be going on in the church.
To make a long story short, the Elkins Church of Christ split on March 21, 2021. Half of the members of one family stayed, and the other half left to attend another congregation.
It started several months ago when Brian Womack, elder, wanted to buy a commercial food warmer ($1,700) and commercial coffee pot ($400) to use in our annex room. I am the other elder (Earl Sutton), and I said no, that a small church like Elkins does not need to spend that kind of money on commercial kitchen equipment. I reminded him that we have three aging AC units that will need to be replaced along with new duct work. I wanted to reserve money and not have to go to the bank and sign a loan for the church (that I have done in the past).
I put an article on Facebook on March 11 in support of the elders at West Sparta Church of Christ. This church was in the process of withdrawing fellowship from a member who was living with someone not her husband. (The letter to this woman was put on the “Woodbury TN Chatter” FB page on March 10. My article was put on this site on March 11. Both posts were taken down on March 11 by the site’s administrator.) My article was also put on Elkins website (www.churchofchristatelkins.org). Those responsible for the split have fixed this website where it is no longer accessible by the public.
Elder Brian Womack had a member of his wife’s family, Steven Davis (son of Jeff Davis) who had married a woman with a living husband, call me and complain about the article. He accused me of stirring up trouble in the church. Before these two married, I approached elder Brian Womack to ask if she had a scriptural right to remarry (Matt. 19:9). Brian Womack said he did not see a problem.
Elder Brian Womack, preacher Bryan Hayes, and deacon Jeff Davis asked to meet with me on Saturday, March 20. Brian Womack accused me of putting inappropriate n**e pictures of women and posts with cuss words in them on Facebook. I have refuted this by finding on FB where my account has been hacked. He accused me of lying. The hacker had set up a fake page in my name on FB.
I was also charged with being too political since I supported President Trump. I fully explained the need to stand up for the truth and biblical principles.
All three resigned, with Brian Womack angrily throwing his key on the floor as he left. After I left the building, they got a locksmith out and changed the door locks behind my back. They also called or visited most members to tell them that at 9:00 a.m. Sunday, March 21, a vote would be taken to remove Earl Sutton as elder and make him leave. They were able to get a lot of unfaithful members to show up, some we see maybe 3-4 times a year. They also had Sheriff deputies present to make sure I didn’t act up. The deputies told me I would not be allowed to defend myself at the 9:00 vote. They stacked the deck.
I simply walked away because of two reasons: (1) not splitting the church (2) not all members arrive at 9 a.m.
I feel the reasons for this coup were rebellious hearts (Jeremiah 5:23), power and control of the church bank accounts. Brian Womack and Jeff Davis want to prevent Steven Davis from leaving Elkins. Brian Hayes wants a permanent preaching position and to move back to the county. His wife is very ambitious for him in helping him build up a resume and networking contacts.
These three have split the church at Elkins for selfish reasons and will have to answer to God for, “A false witness that speaks lies, and sowing discord among brethren” (Prov. 6:19). This God hates and is an abomination unto him.
I have established my reputation in Cannon County over a period of 75 years as being a truthful, honest, preacher, elder and a good citizen. I solemnly state that this is the truth and nothing but the truth.
Earl Sutton, former elder
the church that Christ built...In Matthew chapter 16, Jesus asked His disciples who that men said that He was. They answered with the opinions of men that our Lord was possibly some of the greatest examples of faith and merit in the Bible with such names as "Elijah" and "John the Immerser" or e...