08/25/2026
While this is from a LCMS site, I thought the content equally applies to our church:
There is a temptation facing the Church in every generation, but perhaps especially in ours: to measure the success of Christ’s Church by the same standards the world uses to measure success. How many people are in the pews? How full is the parking lot? How large is the budget? How many programs are running? How many people are watching online? How quickly are we growing? These are not necessarily bad questions, but they become dangerous questions when their answers become the standard by which we determine whether the Church is successful.
And to be clear, there is nothing wrong with wanting the Church to grow. Do we want full churches? Absolutely. Do we want crowded parking lots? Of course. Do we want children being baptized, adults being catechized, families joining congregations, and sinners hearing the Gospel? Yes, yes, and yes! We ought to pray fervently for such things. We ought to invite our neighbors, teach our children, evangelize our communities, and rejoice whenever God brings another sinner into His Church. But numbers are not the measure of faithfulness, and a large congregation is not necessarily a faithful congregation any more than a small congregation is necessarily a dying one.
This is where Luther’s distinction between the theology of glory and the theology of the cross becomes enormously important. The theology of glory looks for God where the world expects to find Him—in strength, power, success, popularity, influence, and visible triumph. The theology of the cross finds God precisely where human reason would never think to look: in weakness, suffering, rejection, and ultimately in a crucified Man hanging between two criminals. By every worldly measurement, Good Friday looked like a catastrophic failure. The crowds had disappeared. The disciples had scattered. Peter had denied Him. Judas had betrayed Him. The religious establishment rejected Him. Rome crucified Him. There was no packed auditorium, impressive organization, measurable momentum, or full parking lot. There was simply Jesus Christ nailed to a cross. And there God was saving the world.
That ought to radically change the way Christians talk about “success.” A congregation of 1,500 people can be spiritually starving while a congregation of 35 people gathers around Christ’s Word and Sacraments and receives the treasures of heaven. A church can have an overflowing parking lot while preaching very little about sin, repentance, Christ crucified, Baptism, Absolution, or the Lord’s Supper. Conversely, a struggling little congregation can hear the pure Gospel preached, receive Christ’s true body and blood, baptize its children, teach the Catechism, sing the faith, absolve repentant sinners, and bury its dead in the certain hope of the resurrection. By the world’s standards it may appear unsuccessful, but by the theology of the cross something glorious is happening there: Christ is present among His people distributing the gifts He won at Calvary.
That is something we in the LCMS desperately need to remember. Yes, our Synod has experienced significant membership decline. Yes, many congregations are smaller than they once were. Yes, demographic realities can be sobering. We should take those realities seriously. We should evangelize. We should invite our neighbors. We should teach our children. We should plant churches where possible and strengthen struggling congregations. Faithfulness is never an excuse for laziness or indifference toward the lost. Christ has commanded His Church to make disciples of all nations, and we should pursue that mission vigorously and joyfully.
But declining numbers should never send us into a panic that causes us to sacrifice our Lutheran identity and confession simply to get more people through the doors. We need to stop acting as though we are responsible for saving Christ’s Church. Christ has already saved His Church. Jesus said, “I will build My church, and the gates of hell shall not prevail against it” (Matthew 16:18). Notice the subject of that sentence: “I.” Christ builds His Church. Christ preserves His Church. Christ gathers His sheep. Christ gives His Word. Christ gives Baptism. Christ gives His body and blood. Christ forgives sins. Christ raises the dead. The Church belongs to Him.
That means we do not need gimmicks to rescue Christianity or the LCMS for that matter. We do not need to dilute doctrine to make Jesus more marketable. We do not need to hide our Lutheran identity because somebody might find it strange. We do not need to turn the Divine Service into entertainment because the congregation down the road has better attendance. What we need is faithfulness. “Faith comes from hearing, and hearing through the word of Christ” (Romans 10:17). The Holy Spirit creates faith where and when it pleases God through the Gospel. Our task is not to manufacture results. Our task is to preach the Word, administer the Sacraments according to Christ’s institution, catechize the faithful, love our neighbors, confess Christ boldly, and leave the results to God.
So, when someone says, “The LCMS is hemorrhaging members!” we should certainly care. We should examine ourselves. We should repent wherever we have grown complacent. We should work diligently to reach those outside the Church. But we should not panic. The future of Christ’s Church does not rest upon our strategic plans, demographic projections, marketing campaigns, or ability to keep institutional machinery running. God had His Church long before the LCMS existed, and should the Lord tarry, He will have His Church long after every institution we know has disappeared. The Bride belongs to the Bridegroom, and no power on earth or in hell can take her from Him (John 10:28-29).
So yes, pray for growth. Invite people. Evangelize boldly. Fill the pews. Fill the parking lot. Baptize babies. Catechize adults. Welcome families. Preach to thousands if God gives the opportunity. But never purchase numbers with the currency of compromised doctrine. Better a little flock gathered around the pure Word of Christ than a stadium filled by withholding it. Jesus says, “Fear not, little flock, for it is your Father’s good pleasure to give you the kingdom” (Luke 12:32). Christ will preserve His Church. Our calling is not to save her but to be faithful within her: preach Christ crucified and risen again, administer His gifts, trust His promises, and leave the numbers to God. Remember, God WILL HAVE HIS CHURCH!