08/08/2025
8/7 - Message From Rabbi Jodie
Today we experienced the resilience of Israeli society in places filled with intense meaning, deep pain, and perhaps a pinch of hope.
We began at ADI NegevâNahalat Eran, âThe Jewel of the Negev,â a rehabilitation village founded by Major General (Res.) Doron Almog in memory of his son, Eran. Originally known as ALEH Negev and built by the ALEH organization, the community was inspired by Eranâs experiences and shaped by Almogâs vision and leadership. Here, 170 residents live full time, 200 patients attend daily programs, and outpatient and inpatient services, including specialized treatment for PTSD, are offered to some of the neediest members of Israeli society, those with severe developmental and physical challenges. On the wall is the phrase ת××× ×× × ×Š×××, Tamid ani shave, âI am always worth your effort.â This is more than a slogan, it is the moral foundation of this place. Plans are already underway to create a fully accessible residential community in the next decade where people with and without disabilities will live side by side in full inclusion.
We left ADI Negev and traveled along Route 241, knowing it was the road terrorists used on October 7 to reach and decimate the city of Ofakim. That awareness shadowed our arrival at Kibbutz Nir Oz, where we met one survivor and came face to face with the devastation of that day. She told us, âWe know how to live in a war zone. We know how to talk to our kids. But this is different.â On October 7, seventy six people from Nir Oz were taken hostage. Until 10:30 a.m., the terrorists kept capturing people, then, after being told they had âenough hostages,â they began killing. She described how her husband became âthe lockâ for their safe room. She spoke of feeling abandoned, knowing that four and a half hours before 6:29 a.m., those in power knew something was going to happen, yet no one warned them.
The dining hall, once the vibrant hub of kibbutz life, is now a memorial. In front of some homes, signs read, âNetanyahu, the blood of my family is on your hands,â âMurderer,â âTraitor,â âDo not enter,â âDo not stand,â âDo not make impure.â The grief here is tangled with frustration and political outrage. The kibbutz faces complicated choices, dealing with the needs of many families, deciding whether to rebuild, leave, or start anew. For years, only âold timersâ wanted to live here, and before October 7 young families were beginning to buy in, thanks to kibbutz movement incentives.
As I walked through, I wrestled with the tension between voyeurism and bearing witness. What information do I need to truly bear witness? Walking through othersâ homes and sifting through their lives is uncomfortable. Yet by standing by the mailboxes or seeing the flags, I could take in the devastation as a whole. Who has the right to do this? How do we mourn as individuals and as a community? Ultimately, we were reminded that we visit not only to tell a terrible story, but to commit ourselves to work for good, for peace among all people, and to insist that what we share as human beings must outweigh what divides us.
Our final stop was Sderot, where we met George Stevens, a young American immigrant and youth movement counselor who lives in an âurban kibbutzâ through the Dror Israel movement. Sderot was first settled by North African and Yemenite Jews who were sent here by the government without choice and without recognition for building the city. Once politically aligned with Labor, it has become more right wing, shaped by decades of rocket fire from Gaza. Every bus stop is a bomb shelter, and the government now requires safe rooms in all new homes. George wants people to settle here and reclaim the pioneer spirit once reserved for kibbutzim.
Central to his work, at least before October 7, was partnering with Palestinians in Gaza who still believe in peace and work toward a shared truth. He described the â10/7 narrativeâ that Israelâs best air force would arrive to save them, and how that faith was broken. He spoke of how, for some, if the person approaching is Israeli, they are coming to save you, and if they are not, they are coming to kill you. He named the âPR of victimhoodâ and the way each side projects foreshadowing of danger. His belief is that Hamas cannot remain in charge, but that moderate Palestinian voices must be supported.
George calls his philosophy peace realism, a blend of what he terms âradical pragmatismâ and Yitzhak Rabinâs approach, âFight terrorism as if thereâs no peace process, and work for peace as if thereâs no terror.â He spoke of two opposite worldviews in Israel, one believing everything will be fine if enough terrorists are killed, the other believing everything will be fine if violence is abandoned entirely. In his view, both military action and diplomacy are essential tools, and true security will only come through peace, just as peace will only be attainable when security is ensured. Since October 7, however, nearly all of his contacts and cross border projects have stopped.
As the day ended, we each found ways to absorb it. Some went to the beach, others walked. I walked for hours, noticing, breathing, and simply being present. We gathered later for a beautiful dinner, thank you, Rebecca, for finding the place, carrying with us the weight and the meaning of all we had heard and seen.