Sephardic Jewish Congregation, Forest Hills

Sephardic Jewish Congregation, Forest Hills Sephardic Jewish Congregation "Kehilat Shaarei Rachamim" is the first established shul in Forest Hills, NY that provides jewish services

10/23/2019

Dvar Torah

Rb. E. Mansour

The Special Protection of Succot

There is a beautiful Derasha (homily) said by the Rabbis in interpreting a passage from the daily Amida prayer, in which we describe Hashem as "Melech Ozer U’moshi’a U’magen" ("King who assists, brings salvation and protects"). These four words, the Rabbis teach, refer to the four significant time-periods of the month of Tishri. The word "Melech" ("king") corresponds to Rosh Hashanah, when we proclaim God’s Kingship over the earth. The second word, "Ozer" ("assists"), alludes to the Aseret Yemeh Teshuba (Ten Days of Repentance), when God helps us repent and draw closer to Him. "Moshi’a" ("brings salvation") refers to Yom Kippur, when God mercifully cleanses and purifies us from our sins, thus saving us from punishment. Finally, the term "Magen" ("protects") alludes to Succot. On Succot, we leave the comfort and security of our homes, which are equipped with locks and alarm systems, and live in the unstable, unprotected environment of the Succa, where we are exposed to the elements, placing our trust in God, confident that He will protect us. As the verse states in Tehillim, "Ki Yispeneni Be’suko" – "For He protects me in His Succa." When we leave our homes and enter the Succa, we leave the security of our manmade dwellings and enter the security of God’s special protection.

We may, however, offer a different explanation for the correspondence between "Magen" and Succot. Throughout the period of the Yamim Nora’im, we’ve worked on ourselves and ascended to high spiritual levels. With the conclusion of the High Holidays, we need to "protect" and preserve these precious achievements – and this is one of the main purposes of Succot. We celebrate this holiday in order to protect what we’ve gained during the season of repentance, to ensure that we retain our high level of spirituality for at least another week, which will then, hopefully, allow us to retain this level for the next several weeks and months. This is the meaning of "Magen" – Succot helps us protect the great achievements that we’ve made during the period of Rosh Hashanah, the Aseret Yemeh Teshuba, and Yom Kippur.

Immediately after Succot, on Shemini Aseret, we begin reciting in the Amida, "Mashib Ha’ru’ah U’morid Ha’geshem," which literally means, "He who makes the wind blow and brings down the rain." One Rabbi, however, quipped that once the holidays of Tishri end, "Mashib Ha’ru’ah" – people return the "Ru’ah," the spirituality that they experienced during the holidays, and "Morid Ha’geshem" – they bring down the "Gashmiyut," the indulgence in physical and material pursuits. Let us avoid this tendency and see to it that all the hard work we invested during the season of the Yamim Nora’im will not be for naught. Let us protect and preserve those accomplishments, so that they will continue to motivate and inspire us to reach even greater levels of spirituality during the weeks and months ahead.

10/23/2019

Dvar Torah

Rb. E. Mansour

Kal Nidrei - Yom Kippur

The prophet Amos states, "The lion has roared - who will not fear" (Amos 3:8). The rabbis teach us that the letters which spell lion (aryeh) - Alef, Resh, Yod, and Heh – refer to Ellul, Rosh Hashana, Yom Kippur and Hoshana Rabba. As we enter into the mouth of the lion, Yom Kippur, we must discuss the teshuva of Yom Kippur.

The Yom Kippur prayers begin with Kal Nidrei. Everyone makes an effort to attend the Kal Nidrei Service, and holding the Sefer Torah for Kal Nidrei is one of the greatest honors. Even the tune is solemn. What makes the prayer so special? After all, in essence, Kal Nidrei is merely a prayer, asking for forgiveness for not fulfilling our vows and oaths. Why do we open the Yom Kippur service with this prayer? While swearing falsely is certainly a great sin, why is specifically this sin the focus of the beginning of Yom Kippur?

On the one hand, from a historical perspective, this may relate to the Jews of Medieval Spain, who were forced to publicly accept Christianity during the Inquisition. These Jews become known as the Marannos. The Marannos would gather each year, in hiding, to ask forgiveness for the vow they made to accept Christianity. They sang this prayer in a solemn, even morbid tune. They asked God to be absolved for their vow to Christianity. However, we didn’t vow to Christianity, and nowadays, we do not swear or take vows, certainly not in God’s name. So why is this prayer still the beginning of our Yom Kippur prayers?

The Talmud (Nida 30b) teaches about life in the womb. The gemara describes how as birth approaches, each child is made to take an oath that he will "be righteous, and be never wicked." The angel then warns the child that he should "always bear in mind that the Holy One, blessed be He, is pure, that his ministers are pure and that the soul which He gave you is pure; if you preserve it in purity, well and good, but if not, I will take it away from you."

As Yom Kippur approaches, we review the previous year, and we realize that we did not live up to the oath we took as we entered this world. Therefore, we pray to God that we should be absolved of that oath, the oath which every Jew took. We even take a Sefer Torah, upon which the oath was taken, as we ask God forgiveness for using the Torah as the object of our false oath. We pray to God that we should be forgiven for that oath, and God says, "vesalahti lidvarecha"- and "I have forgiven you."

The prayers of Yom Kippur have so much meaning and depth. In one prayer, we describe God as "goleh amukot" – "God reveals the depths." The Talmud teaches that "af al pi shehata yisrael hu"- a person cannot abdicate his Judaism. Even the worst of the Jews, in the depth of their souls, is a spark of holiness. Eventually, if that spark is cultivated, it can ignite, and the person can do teshuva. Although we don’t always see this, God is "goleh amukot"- he sees the depths of our souls and shows the prosecuting angels how every Jew is good.

We see this idea in a famous Rambam. The Rambam (Hilchot Gerushin 2:20) teaches that if a person who bet din ruled must divorce his wife refuses to give her a get (a writ of divorce), even though a get must be given out of his free will, "kofin oto ad sheyomar rose ani"- he can be forced until he agrees. The Rambam explains sine "he wants to be part of the Jewish people, and he wants to perform all the misvot and eschew all the transgressions; it is only his evil inclination that presses him; therefore, when he is beaten until his [evil] inclination has been weakened, and he consents [to the divorce], he is considered to have performed the divorce willfully." In other words, deep down he wants to do the proper thing, and at times, he may not even realize this.

The gemara (Avoda Zara 17a) relates that a fellow named Elazar ben Durdai had a specific weakness: he had sexual relations with every zona (pr******te) in the world. Once, he heard that there was a pr******te in a faraway place. He crossed seven rivers and brought a full purse of dinarim, and came to this woman. As he was about to sin with her, God decided that it was time to send Elazar ben Durdai a message. The Talmud relates that the pr******te passed gas, and then she said to Elazar ben Durdai: Just like this gas will never return to its place, so too Elazar ben Durdai will never return to God. He went outside, put his head between his knees, and cried so intensely that he died. He literally died of teshuva. A heavenly voice declared, "R. Eleazar ben Durdia is ready for the world-to-come."

There are many lessons to be learned from this episode. The Maharal offered an explanation based upon Elazar ben Durdai’s name – "God (E-l) helps (azar) Elazar when he was at the bottom of the barrel (durdai)." When he was in the worst place, rock-bottom, God helped him.

This story comes to teach is that even when we are in the worst place, God is a "goleh amukot," and knows that deep down we are good.

10/23/2019

Dvar Torah

Rb. Y. Frand

Elul / Rosh Hashanah
The Uniqueness Of Rosh HaShana’s Judgment

The second Mishna of tractate Rosh Hashana teaches “On Rosh Hashana all who enter the world pass before Him (for judgment) like Bnei Maron” (sheep being counted). However, the Gemara there quotes an opinion that “Man is judged daily” [Rosh Hashana 16a]. At first glance, these two opinions seem to conflict with one another. Apparently, Judgment either occurs once a year or it occurs on a daily basis. The two opinions seem to be mutually exclusive.
Rav Eizele Charif tries to reconcile these statements by introducing the concept that that in reality, there are two types of judgment. When a person starts his year, it has been determined that he has certain abilities, a certain status, and certain physical and financial attributes. A status quo for the coming year is determined on Rosh HaShana. However, this “baseline” can be altered during the year — for better or for worse — based on the actions of the individual during the year.
However, when we approach the judgment of the New Year, there is no status quo. We do not approach the Almighty with a presumption of what has been (chazaka d’m’ikara). We do not walk into Judgment on Rosh HaShana with the idea “I have been alive until now, I will remain alive this coming year; I have been healthy and wealthy until now, so it will all continue indefinitely during the coming year”. That is not a correct attitude on Rosh HaShana.
During the year, our allotment and budget has already been determined. We have been budgeted a certain amount of dollars, and health, and success in our endeavors and we proceed to spend against that pre-determined budget, even though that budget can be raised or lowered within the parameters of “Man is judged daily”. However, when Rosh HaShana’s judgment for the New Year arrives, there is nothing that is a given.
Rav Pam once commented on the Penitential prayer that we say in Selichos prior to and during the Yomim Noraim (Days of Awe), “Like paupers and beggars do we come before You, knocking on Your door.” The simple interpretation is that we are paupers because we do not have sufficient good deeds to our credit. However, Rav Pam says that it is to be interpreted literally — when we appear before the Almighty on Rosh HaShana we are penniless. What does it mean we are penniless? I have money in the bank, I have a portfolio, I have a house, and I have assets! What does it mean, “I’m a pauper”?
Rav Pam explains that it means that nothing is a given. We start out afresh. There are not any “chazakas”. “You were healthy until now, but today there is a fresh judgment regarding what is going to happen now and for the coming year.” “You had success until now. Today there is a fresh Judgment.”
The reason we do not tremble before the Yom HaDin is because it is very hard for us to actually believe this idea. If a person is 50 years old, he figures that he has been through all this previously and things always seem to remain fairly stable. He assumes “Look, I just went for a physical and the doctor says I am doing quite well.” “I have been in my business or profession for 30 years; some years I do a little better and some years a little worse, but I have always had a steady income. What do you mean that I might not have parnasa this coming year?” We tend to assume that we are going into the Day of Judgment with a strong status quo in our favor. That is not true. It is very difficult for us to internalize this concept but the status quo is not guaranteed.
If we think about things we have seen and heard about during the past year, it will become all too clear how life can change in a minute. People are swept away by natural tragedies, by sudden changes of fortune, by unexpected diagnoses, and by unforeseen political changes. These sudden changes in one’s health or fortune or personal status are the most shocking things that can happen to a person. Yesterday, everything was wonderful. Overnight, things can change in such a way that a person is no longer able to function. However, such events do occur. That is the Day of Judgment of Rosh Hashana. There are no presumptions of status quo. We cannot be lulled into this false sense of security that we have been healthy, wealthy, and wise until now, presumably it will continue like that as well.
On Rosh Hashana, all bets are off. Like paupers and penniless people do we knock on Your doors. This is the reality. This is why the Din of Rosh Hashana is so awesome and scary.

10/23/2019

Dvar Torah - KiTavo

Rb. E. Mansour

The Torah in Parashat Ki-Tabo discusses the Misva of Bikkurim. During the times of the Bet Hamikdash, a Jew who grew fruits was required to bring the first fruits that ripened to the Temple and present them as a gift to the Kohen.

There is a fascinating Halacha relevant to Bikkurim that, while counterintuitive, provides us with a fundamental lesson concerning Torah life. Everyone who brought Bikkurim to the Mikdash had to bring the fruits in a basket. Surprisingly, though, it was only the baskets of the poor that were given to the Kohen together with the fruits. The wealthier Jews brought their Bikkurim in lavish, ornate baskets, and the Kohen took the fruits and allowed the people to keep their baskets. But when a poor man came with his Bikkurim in a simple, ordinary basket, the Kohen kept the fruits and the basket. The Talmud comments regarding this Halacha, "The poor get poorer" – the poor people lose more from this Misva than the wealthy ones do.

The obvious question arises as to why this should be the case. Shouldn’t the multimillionaire be the one to surrender his basket along with his fruits? Why does the Torah impose an additional financial burden specifically upon the poor man?

The answer lies in the well-known rule of "Rahamana Liba Ba’i" – Hashem wants, first and foremost, the heart, the sincere effort. Unlike in our professional lives, where results are what counts, when it comes to Torah the most important thing is the work and effort that we invest. As long as we sincerely work toward achieving results, God values our efforts regardless of our bottom-line achievements.

When a wealthy magnate brings his first fruits to Jerusalem, he walks into a shop in the hotel lobby, sees an exquisite silver bowl, pulls out his credit card to make the purchase, and asks the concierge to bring it to his room and place in it the fruits on the table. He later hops into a cab with his Bikkurim and brings it to the Bet Hamikdash. The poor man, however, walks into a florist shop, asks for some leftover leaves and twigs, and then spends several hours weaving them together into a makeshift basket for his Bikkurim. After all, this is all he can afford to do. When these two people come together to the Bet Hamikdash, the Kohen asks for the poor man’s basket. God cherishes the hard work and sacrifice that the poor man invested into this Misva, and it is therefore specifically his basket that the Kohen, as God’s representative, keeps. The wealthy man has certainly not done anything wrong. To the contrary, he has performed the great Misva of Bikkurim. But there is something special about the poor man’s basket, about the work and effort that he invested, and this is what the Almighty values the most.

Today, a person can arrange three lavish Shabbat meals by just picking up the phone and placing an order. The caterer does all the cooking, setting up, serving and cleaning. Nobody could criticize those who make Shabbat in this way; in fact, it is admirable to spend money for the honor of Shabbat. But at the same time, there is much to be said for the personal effort and toil, working hard to prepare Shabbat. Something is lost when we delegate the work involved in preparing for Misvot.

This is true regarding the Sukka, as well. Today, people don’t want to have a hassle, so everyone has "the guy" who builds their Sukka for them. And, Baruch Hashem, many people bring great honor to the Misva by hiring workers to build them magnificent Sukkot. But we must not overlook the value of personally involving oneself in the hard work of Misvot. Not everything should be delegated. Hashem cherishes not only the final result, but also the work we invest in the process.

The Arizal taught that when a person perspires for the sake of a Misva, those drops of perspiration are stored and serve as a means of atonement for all his sons. One Rabbi I knew would participate each year in the baking of Masot for Pesah, and specifically chose the job of standing next to the scorching hot oven, putting in and removing the Masot. He said that this way he perspires the most, thus maximizing his reward for involving himself in this great Misva.

When it comes to Misva performance, we should not always find the most convenient way, even if we can afford it. It is worthwhile to "weave our own baskets," to personally involve ourselves in the hard work, thereby demonstrating our love for the Misvot and our unwavering devotion to the One who commanded them.

The Elul Immersion

The significance of this month – the month of Elul – can be understood based on the laws of "Bittul," whereby a small amount of forbidden food becomes "nullified" when mixed with a much larger quantity of permissible food.

The basic rule is that when a small amount of forbidden food is mixed with permissible food, the mixture is permissible if the amount of permissible food is 60 times greater than the amount of forbidden food. This famous Halachic concept is called "Bittul Be’shishim."

However, there are a number of exceptions, including that of a "Beriya" – a whole entity. According to the Talmud Babli (Babylonian Talmud), a whole entity, such as an entire insect, cannot ever be "nullified" in a mixture. No matter how small a percentage of the mixture the "Beriya" comprises, the mixture is still forbidden for consumption. The Talmud Yerushalmi, however, presents a different view, establishing that a "Beriya" is "nullified" if the proportion is 960:1. If the whole entity comprises just 1/960th of the mixture, then the mixture becomes permissible.

This concept is relevant also to the "nullification" of our beings. Each person is a "Beriya," and we’ve become contaminated through sin. In order to cleanse and purify ourselves, we must "nullify" our defective beings and emerge as new creatures, embarking on a fresh start with a clean slate.

A Mikveh, which brings purity to somebody who has become defiled, must consist of 40 "Se’a" of water. A "Se’a" is a Talmudic measurement of volume, equal to 24 "Log," and thus a Mikveh requires 960 "Log" of water to bring purity. Immersion in a Mikveh symbolizes our process of "Bittul," the "nullification" of our beings so we can begin creating ourselves anew.

When G-d determined that the world become irreparably corrupted during the time of Noah, He brought a flood that lasted for 40 days, or 960 hours (40 X 24). In order to "nullify" the world so it could start anew, He "immersed" the world it water, submerging it in floodwaters for 960 hours, corresponding to the 960 "Log" of water in a Mikveh.

The period of Elul and the High Holidays functions as a Mikveh. For 40 days, from the first day of Elul through Yom Kippur on the 10th of Tishri, we "immerse" ourselves in introspection and repentance. Just as a Mikveh requires 960 "Log," and not a single "Log" fewer, our process of "immersion" during this period requires us to make the most of every hour of these 40 days so we can emerge pure and pristine.

This 40-day period concludes at the end of Yom Kippur, after we read the Book of Yona, which tells how Yona spent 40 days inside the whale, which then expelled Yona onto the shore. After our 40-day period of repentance, we are "expelled" from this "Mikveh." The special opportunity we are given for purification and forgiveness lasts only for these 40 days. We must therefore take full advantage of each and every hour of this critical period.

In the final chapter of Tehillim, which we include in the Musaf prayer on Rosh Hashanah, King David proclaims, "Haleluhu Be’tof U’mahol" – which literally means, "praise Him with drums and dances." Additionally, however, the word "Tof" has the numerical value of 480, and thus the word "Be’tof" may be read as "Bet" – "Tof," meaning, twice the value of "Tof," or 960. If we use these 960 hours properly, then "Be’mahol" – we are granted "Mehila" (forgiveness).

May we all take full advantage of each and every moment of this most precious time of year, so we emerge from Yom Kippur in a newfound state of purity and holiness, prepared to make this year far better than the previous one, Amen.

10/23/2019

Dvar Torah - KiTetze
Rb. Y Frand

Setting Aside A “Yerach Yomim” For Mourning Our Past: A “Beautiful” Insight Into “Yefas Toar”

In the beginning of this week’s parsha, the Torah teaches us a Halacha [Jewish Law] that is one of the most difficult Halachos to understand — the Halacha of the “Yefas Toar” (beautiful captive woman). The Torah, under certain circumstances, gives permission to the soldier who falls in love with a beautiful non-Jewish woman on the battlefield to take her as his wife, provided that she converts to Judaism. The conversion process involves the following: She is brought into his house, her head is shaved, her clothes of captivity are removed, and she mourns for her parents for 30 days. After this process the soldier is allowed to marry her.
The Zohar, on this parsha, says that the 30-day period in which the woman cries for the loss of her parents is the month of Elul. [Elul, which began this past Friday, is the Hebrew month preceding Rosh HaShana.] What is the connection between the mourning of the “Yefas Toar” for her parents and the month of Elul?
The pasuk [verse] uses interesting terminology to describe the 30-day period. The pasuk calls this period “Yerach Yamim” (literally a moon’s worth of days). The more common term would be a Chodesh (a month).
There is an interesting halachic practice — when a Kesuvah (marriage document) is dated, the date is specified as being of a certain Chodesh; however when a Get (divorce document) is dated, the date is specified as being of a certain Yerach. The reason for this difference is that in the Hebrew language the word Yerach has the connotation of “ending” a month; while the word Chodesh (related to chadash — new) has the connotation of the “beginning” of a month.
That is why the Torah uses the term “Yerach Yamim”. The Torah is telling her that if she wishes to convert to Judaism and begin a new life, she must close the chapter on her last life. The Zohar tells us that “her father and her mother” refers to her idolatry. She must contemplate her past association with idolatry and say good-bye to it. Before she can contemplate the new beginning, she must regret the fallacy of the false gods and meaningless pagan worship. That is how she is to spend this entire closing month – Yerach.
What is the significance of the month of Elul? Elul is that special month that a person needs in order to contemplate beginning the New Year and the impending Rosh Hashanna. A person cannot just begin the New Year without preparation. Rosh Hashanna must be preceded by a month of contemplation and reflection. We must look back at the previous year — asking ourselves, “Where did we go wrong?” “Where did that year go?” “What happened to that year?”
So what does the Zohar mean when he says that mourning for her father and mother “a Yerach Yamim” refers to the month of Elul? It is meaningless for this captive woman to enter Judaism without going through a period of mourning, contemplation, and introspection. Similarly, it is meaningless for us to contemplate “Tik’u b’Chodesh Shofar – Blow the Shofar on the (beginning of) the New Month (Rosh Hashanna)” unless there is some preparation and contemplation about the year that was. If not, we cannot hold out much hope for the beginning of the New Year.
Of all the Jewish Holidays, it is the Yomim Noraim (Days of Awe) that require the greatest preparation. We cannot just arrive in shul on the Eve of Rosh Hashanna and say, “Now is the time to start repenting.” It cannot happen all of a sudden like that. We cannot spiritually turn around on a dime. It requires a process — a Yerach Yomim, a chodesh Elul.
Unfortunately, for those of us in the working world with all the distractions of making a living, the beginning of school, and all the other things that divert our attention – this is so difficult. Most of us are not in Yeshiva anymore, we are not able to have a Mussar Seder (a fixed daily period for studying ethical works), we can not sit and think, we do not have the time to daven properly, as Yeshiva students do.
However, it is a necessity that we all have to try to prepare properly for the Yomim Noraim. We need that Yerach Yomim so we can properly arrive at “Tik’u b’Chodesh Shofar” – the blowing of the Shofar on Rosh Hashanna.

10/23/2019

Dvar Torah - Shoftim
Rb. Y Frand

The Torah is not talking to HIM; the Torah is talking to YOU

“You shall place judges and policemen in all your gates, and they shall judge the people justly [Devorim 16:18]. This is a positive Biblical command to establish a judicial system. The first pasukim [verses] of the parsha — which warn against judicial corruption, bribe taking, etc. — are actually commands directed at the Beis Din [the Jewish Court]. That being the case, the grammatical structure of the narration is peculiar.
The Torah begins by saying that you (the nation) should appoint judges. We would expect the continuation to be “They (the appointed judges) should not show favoritism, take bribes, etc.” Instead the Torah continues to use the second person throughout: “You should not show favoritism, you should not take bribes, etc.”
Rav Nissan Alpert suggests a homiletic interpretation. We tend to think that there are unique laws that apply to judges, just like there are — for example — unique laws that apply to Kohanim (priests). Our inclination is to believe that just as the laws of the priesthood only apply to Kohanim and not to others, so too, the judicial laws only apply to judges and not to others.
This is incorrect. Everyone in life is a judge. We are almost constantly judging. When we meet someone, the first thing that we do is to judge him. We are confident — based on the way a person looks or dresses — that we are 100% accurate in our judgement. We have him pegged perfectly. We check the Yarmulka — is it black, is it velvet, is it knitted, is it this, is it that. We check the kind of clothes he is wearing. We judge people right away. People do things and we jump to immediate conclusions.
The Torah is acknowledging this phenomenon and telling us “You — all of you — are inevitably going to judge; but just like judges have an obligation to judge fairly and not take bribes or be influenced by outside events — every Jew has that obligation. “YOU should not turn aside justice.” The Torah is not talking to HIM (the judge); the Torah is talking to YOU!
A friend does something wrong. We should really tell him about it, but we do not. Why not? Because we have taken a bribe. We have taken his friendship; we have received favors from him; we have established a relationship; we are now afraid to hurt the relationship. That is a bribe. The Torah tells us “You shall not take a bribe” — do not let this bribe, which you have already accepted, influence you.
Every person is a judge and every person has the obligation to judge fairly. We learn in Pirkei Avos [Ethics of the Fathers 1:1] “Be deliberate in judgement”. Here too, we are tempted to dismiss these teachings as being directed solely at the judges. No. It is written for all of us. We are all judges charged with being fair, equitable and deliberate and not jumping to conclusions. We are inevitably going to be judges and we must act like judges.

“Today’s Leaders?” — Borrowing the Yetzer Horah’s Rhetoric

Another pasuk [verse] at the beginning of the parsha teaches us, “And you will come to the Priests and the Levites and to the Judge who will be there in those days” [Bamidbar 17:9]. Rash”i presents his very famous insight that it is inconceivable for a person to bring his Din Torah [Judgement] to a Judge who lived in different era! Of course the person will bring the case in front of a judge who is there during that period of time! Rather, the Torah is telling us that even if the Judge does not measure up to the Judges of prior times, one must abide by the rulings of the contemporary judges.
Rash”i was speaking prophetically. I assume that every generation suffers from this, but in our generation the problem is particularly acute. Some people, who had the merit to see the Gedolei Yisroel [Great (Sages) of Israel] from the past generation, often say, “Now that, was a great person!” But people often bemoan the fact that “there are no more Gedolim (Great Rabbis) any more”. Rash”i’s insight addresses this attitude. Every generation is given its leaders and judges, and these are the ones to whom the generation must turn for guidance.
Rav Pam offers a beautiful insight in his sefer [book]. In the beginning of Iyov [1:7], G-d said to the Yetzer Horah [Soton/evil inclination], “From where have you come?” The Soton answered, “From wandering and walking about the earth.” Based on the Midrashic interpretation, the Yetzer Horah told G-d that he searched the deeds of mankind from the beginning of time and found no one more righteous than Avraham. This seems out of character for the Yetzer Horah, to be saying something good about someone!
Then G-d asked the Yetzer Horah. “Did you take note of My servant Iyov, for there is no one like him on earth, a wholesome and upright man who fears G-d and shuns evil” [1:8]. The Yetzer Horah responded, “Is it for nothing that Job fears G-d…?” [1:9]
Rav Pam says that this is an example of comparing “today’s Gedolim” with those of years gone by. The only reason why the Yetzer Horah said something good about Avrohom was in order to mock Iyov’s piety — since compared to Avrohom — who was the Gadol of a previous generation — Iyov was nothing!
Rav Pam says that whenever we hear someone speak like that — “Today’s leaders? Who are they?” — that in reality the Yetzer Horah is speaking. This is his language and those are his expressions!
Every generation is tested. Every generation thinks, “who are our leaders today compared to those of yesteryear?”
I recently read a Torah Journal in which Rav Hershel Schachter reminisces about Rav Yosef Dov Soloveitchik, zt”l. Rav Schachter writes of an incident that Rav Soloveitchik related involving his grandfather, the famous Rav Chaim Soloveitchik. When Rav Chaim Solovteichik started saying shiurim (Torah discourses) in the Volozhin Yeshiva, the students complained that Rav Chaim was unworthy of teaching in that Yeshiva. Who is this “Rav Chaim”, anyway? They believed that he only received the position because he married the granddaughter of the Rosh Yeshiva (Rav Naftali Tzvi Yehudah Berln, the Netziv). This was a classic case of “Who are today’s leaders?”
The end of the story is in itself a great ethical lesson. The resolution of this “complaint” was that the yeshiva brought in three “great men of the generation” to rule whether Rav Chaim was worthy to say a shiur in Volozhin. (Rav Schachter writes that he believes that one of these great men was Rav Yitzchak Elchanan).
Rav Chaim began a shiur on the subject of Aylonis (an adult woman without the signs of maturity) in Tractate Yevomos and was in the middle of reconciling a difficult passage of Rambam in his Yad HaChazakah. Rav Chaim suddenly remembered that in the Rambam’s commentary to the Mishneh, the Rambam advances a position that was inconsistent with the whole approach that Rav Chaim was trying to develop.
In front of the three Gedolim, Rav Chaim gave a bang on his lectern and said, “The shiur that I had prepared is not True. My hypothesis was wrong, the Rambam says otherwise in his Mishneh Commentary.” Rav Chaim then sat down.
The three great rabbis concluded, “He is worthy to be a Rosh Yeshiva in Volozhin.” Any person who cares about the truth so much that he is willing to suffer the embarrassment of having to admit his own mistake for the sake of truth, is definitely worthy to be a Rosh Yeshiva in Volozhin.

Address

New York, NY
11375

Telephone

(718) 544-6932

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Sephardic Jewish Congregation, Forest Hills posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Place Of Worship

Send a message to Sephardic Jewish Congregation, Forest Hills:

Share

Category