08/24/2026
Eugenia Williams (1900-1998) is much in the local news lately due to the recent opening of her restored mansion on Lyons View Pike. Her family history is a rich narrative of old and new money, travel and tragedy, and cultural changes during and after world wars, a saga that continues to captivate. To better understand the enigmatic Eugenia, we begin with her grandparents Tully Robinson Cornick, Jr. (1853–1902) and Laura Elvira Sydnor (1855–1895).
Tully Cornick, Jr., was one of 13 children, one of 9 who survived to adulthood; and, like his father Tully Cornick, Sr., was a prominent Knoxville attorney. He was born in Knoxville but in infancy, his family moved to MO where they resided for 13 yrs. They returned to Knoxville, and Tully was educated at UT. He then read law but could not get a license until age 21 in TN, so he ret’d to MO and was admitted to the bar in 1871 at age 18. On Jan 6, 1876, he married Laura Sydnor, the daughter of a Civil War Col. from Troy, MO, an exurb of St. Louis. Ella, Eugenia’s mother, was born exactly 9 mos later on Oct 7. Three more children followed, Tully III, Sydnor, and Howard.
Tully worked primarily in estate law with three successive partners and had an office on Prince Street (now Market St). The 1880s and 90s were the Gilded Age when rail travel spurred luxury tourism, and the Cornicks traveled on holidays—to the Intl Cotton Expo in Atl in 1881, to resorts in Florida, New Orleans, and Biloxi, MS, and to TN’s popular mineral springs: Lea’s, Oliver, Neubert, and Tate.
A side story to railroads could probably fill another chapter. In brief: the firm of Cornick & Shea was also a RR contracting firm. The Cotton Expo had showcased Atlanta's recovery and aimed to attract investment, leading to improvements in infrastructure, including railroads. On March 22, 1884, in the interest of RR expansion, Tully and his partner traveled to Guatemala via the steamship Dallas to meet with President Barrios. Laura, a Miss Lilly Gosselin, sister-in-law of Col. E. A. Lever, foreign editor of the New Orleans Times-Democrat, and two other New Orleans couples were in the party. The Cornicks and Miss Gosselin were to “return on horseback to Port Livingston, over the mountain ranges that intervene between the city of Guatemala and the Caribbean coast and will there take a ship to New Orleans.” In late May, the Times-Democrat reported that “Mr. Cornick has secured for his firm a most valuable and profitable contract to build and equip 62 miles of the line from Pt. Barrios to El Meco, Mexico.” Unfortunately, in 1886, well into construction, there was an uprising in Guatamala which destroyed their profits and broke up the enterprise.
In Aug 1888 Laura leased “an elegant new home on W. Clinch” in front of the post office and planned to open a family hotel which the Tribune predicted would be the “toniest little hotel in the South.” The Oxford opened in Oct, but nine months later the entire contents were sold at auction, and the new hotel was soon under new management. In 1893 the Cornicks traveled to Chicago for the World’s Fair. Laura spent the summer of 1894 on a ranch near Houston, TX, possibly for her health. In Dec of that year she and Ella traveled to San Antonio to spend the winter in the hope of benefitting Laura’s health. In early Jan 1895 Laura, now ill with consumption (TB), Tully, and 19-yr-old daughter Ella made a second trip to San Antonio, TX, this time hoping to prolong Laura’s life. While there, the couple’s 3-yr-old son Howard, who had been ill during the 3 wks his parents were in TX, died on Jan 25 before they reached home. Laura, it was reported, never left her bed and died on Feb 8 at age 39.
Ella Cornick (1876-1914) attended East TN Female Institute and School of Music 1892-94 and graduated in June with honors. The School had been renamed in 1892 and was under the leadership of Prof Charles Ross and a new faculty. In Dec 1893, the Cornicks held a dinner party in Ella’s honor, “altho not yet formally entered into society,” and 48 “members of the gay society” played a progressive game of hearts at 12 tables. In Aug 1895, six mos after her mother’s death, Ella and a friend made an extended tour of the lake region and along the Canadian border and on the return were entertained by friends in Boston and NYC. In Dec 1895, she attended the second annual reception of the Cumberland Club, a formal affair in the club rooms on Clinch. Two of the members of the Cumberland Club were her father and Dr. David Hitt Williams. In May 1896 she and three female friends took a summer abroad, departing NYC for Glasgow the first week of May and arriving home in late September.
Ella married Dr. David Hitt Williams (1863-1929) on Dec 21, 1896, at St. John’s Episcopal, Rev. Samuel Ringgold officiating. Williams was born in AL and came to Knoxville in 1891 to practice medicine and teach in the Knoxville Medical College. The wedding was called the “crowning social event of the season.” “Hundreds of invitations” were issued, there were throngs in attendance, and two police officers stood at St John’s entrance to make sure all guests were “properly credentialed.” A smaller number attended the reception at Mr. Cornick’s “elegant home” Melrose. The couple honeymooned in FL and returned to a suite of apts in the Vendome. They were a popular addition to the city’s social life. In 1897 Ella was a member of the Ossoli Circle and charter member and treasurer of the newly created Tues Morning Musical Club, and David of the Fortnightly Medical Club. They enjoyed annual vacations at Ponce Park, FL.
The Williamses had three children, Eugenia in 1900, Elizabeth in 1906, and David, Jr., in 1909. Dr. Williams was an avid fisherman, and the Williams family wintered in Fl and had a cottage in Ft. Myers. Eugenia’s younger sister Elizabeth died in 1908 at age 1 yr 9 mos. In 1913, Eugenia entered Birmingham School for Girls, later called Grier School, a boarding school in Birmingham, PA. Her mother was reported to have contracted pneumonia in April, 1914. In June Ella went to Asheville, but on return was “indisposed.” But was it pneumonia? TB was called “the White Plague,” and so prolific locally Knoxville was considering building its own sanatorium. There was a women’s Anti-Tuberculosis League. The Knoxville Red Cross sold anti-TB Christmas Seals. In Aug 1913 at Knoxville’s Conservation Exposition, Dr. Mary Lapham, who had a national reputation as a specialist in the treatment of TB and was the physician at the Highlands Camp Sanatorium in NC, had given a lecture on TB. The Camp had 60 “tent houses” (see photo below) which allowed patients to get fresh cold air and a three-story infirmary with an X-ray machine. In the Camp’s history, hundreds were cured, but around mid-Oct 1914, Ella went to Highlands and died there on Oct 28. Eugenia was 14.
Eugenia returned to Birmingham after her mother’s death and graduated in Jun 1917. David, Jr., had died of rheumatic fever in 1916 at age 7. During summers over the next two years she traveled in PA visiting school friends, and some of those friends visited her in Knoxville. In Nov 6, 1920, Eugenia married Richard Gordon Chandler (1897-1958) in the Fifth Av Presbyterian Church. Unlike her parents, their wedding was witnessed by only members of the two immediate families and, according to the Sentinel, “was unusually beautiful in its simplicity.” Chandler, not long out of WWI military service, was employed in insurance and real estate. Eugenia’s father was initially against the marriage but later, as reported, the two men grew greatly attached to each other as they had much in common, esp hunting and fishing. The Chandlers made a honeymoon tour of Washington, New York, and other eastern cities and first lived in an apt in the McKinney Terrace on W. Main and Locust (now a parking garage).
Chandler seems to have had a more outgoing personality than Eugenia. He inherited much of this from his father, William Porter Chandler, who had long been a popular figure in Knoxville, having progressed from newspaper reporter to editor, then successively to postmaster, police chief, and state senator. Gordon had become a local hero after joining the Expeditionary Forces in France and suffering minor injuries there. He was already a successful businessman, became an avid hunter and trophy fisherman, and owned a series of luxury automobiles, including the first Rolls-Royce in Knoxville in 1931. Eugenia and Gordon had no children and divorced in 1936. Chandler remarried Hazel Gose (1908-1992) in 1938, and they had two children.
In 1938 Eugenia acquired a permit to build a $2K barn to house her mule. She had the plans drawn by architects Barber & McMurray. In 1939 she razed her father’s house and extensive gardens and built the 2-story, river-view mansion on Lyons View Pike designed by Knoxville architect John Fanz Staub. Except for her successive appeals to have her property tax assessment (the largest in Knoxville) reduced, her name was rarely in the news. But it was always on the list of donors to local fundraisers—the Empty Stocking Fund, the Halsey Home for Friendless Babies, the Community Chest, Baptist Hospital Pledge Drive, Knoxville Journal Milk Fund, the Salvation Army.
Amid all the sadness and litigation, we close with a brighter subject in Eugenia’s biography—her close relationship with her grandfather Tully Cornick, Jr.’s second wife, Anne Inglis Scott (1872-1951) of Paterson, NJ. Tully and Anne had met in Orlando in Dec 1896 at a mutual friend’s wedding. “The acquaintance was renewed” the following Apr during Anne’s visit with a Knoxville friend. On Nov 11, 1897, Tully and Anne married in St. Paul’s Episcopal Church in Paterson. Tully was a month shy of 44, and Anne was 25. Eugenia, only three, probably had few memories of her grandmother Laura Cornick. Anne became Eugenia’s step-grandmother, but Eugenia always called her Aunt Annie. Anne became a beloved educator in Knoxville city schools over almost 30 years including 16 years as the city’s first female principal (Boyd Jr Hi 1913-29). Tully and Anne’s only child, Rosa, died in 1900 at age 2. Tully died in 1902 at age 48, and Anne never remarried. In 1916, two years after Ella’s death, Eugenia lived with Anne in an apt in the McKinney Flats, possibly during Eugenia’s holiday breaks from boarding school. For Eugenia’s graduation in 1917, Anne hosted a dinner and theater party for her, and they were still living together that winter. In 1919 the two traveled to Atlantic City. In 1929, David Hitt Williams’ will included a $5,000 bequest to Anne “for her kindness to his family.” David died on Oct 1 and Anne retired a month later, a year before retirement age. The bequest may have been a factor. She traveled with Eugenia and Gordon after their marriage--Aug 1931 to Ft. Myers, Oct 1931 to NYC, Feb and Mar 1932 to FL. Eugenia and Anne also traveled to NYC in May and Oct 1931 and spent several weeks in FL in Nov and Dec 1931.
Anne moved away in the 40s, and we have no record of their relationship after that. Newspaper society pages became “women’s pages,” then shrank to mostly wedding announcements. But we do know that, for a time, these two women—one who had lost an only child, a daughter, and one who had lost her mother—may have enjoyed a special bond.