08/16/2026
August 16, 2026
A simple question (Isaiah 56:1, 6–8 • Psalm 67 • Romans 11:1–2a, 29–32 • Matthew 15:10–28)
I am sure someone, or maybe more, is sitting there wondering, why in the world did we just sing Hark! The Herald Angels Sing on August 16th? It’s a good question, a simple question. And there’s a simple answer – that Christmas carol, just like the hymn we usually sing at Thanksgiving, Now Thank We All Our God, resonate with our scripture readings today.
Our Scripture readings also ask us a simple question, a good question, this morning: which word gets the last word? Is it judgment? Or will it be mercy?
Isaiah is speaking to those who have returned from exile. They probably were expecting everything to be the same as it was before the people had left. But it isn’t. Some are working on rebuilding the Temple, while others try to figure out what community is like. Apparently, there were conversations about who belongs, who counts, who is part of God’s people.
Which shouldn’t surprise us. Every generation, every nation, every organization, even faith communities have such conversations. They never seem to disappear. There is always someone who wants to make the circle a little smaller, take away chairs from the table, develop standards for who is in, and who is not.
Most of us learned how to do that when we were children. Think about the playground at recess when two people were choosing sides for a game. Someone would point: “You’re on our team.” Someone else would point in another direction: “You’re with them.” And then there was always that moment when someone was left standing there, waiting to discover whether anyone would choose them.
We may have grown older, but we never completely outgrow the game. We simply become more sophisticated about drawing the lines. We have better reasons. More complicated explanations. We can make our exclusions sound almost reasonable. But the result can still be the same: you are in; you are out.
But then, Isaiah speaks for God: “my house shall be called a house of prayer for all people.” Not just some. Not the elect, or a select few. Not folks who look alike, talk alike, dress alike, vote alike, worship in the same way. No. All people.
And then God offers a most remarkable, a beautiful promise: “I will gather others to them besides those already gathered.” To people just brought home from exile, God doesn’t brush off the divine hands, saying, “Whew! All done. Time for a nap.” No. God says, “I have a lot more folks to gather.”
In other words, the guest list is not done, the family circle is expanding, God is still adding branches to the family tree.
The writer of Psalm hears that promise, and like a good lyricist, turns it into a song – “Let the peoples praise you, O God; let all the peoples praise you.” And in doing so, it becomes a remarkable prayer. The psalmist is not asking God to choose one nation over another, to bless one country instead of another. No, the writer asks God to bless one particular people so that every people may discover God’s ways.
You see, the psalmist knew that any blessing is never meant to stop with us. We are not to try to patent mercy, or trademark grace. Blessings are not meant to be put in safe deposit boxes but to be passed on to others, with no strings attached. Like sunlight, rain, or seeds carried by the wind. Simply shared with others. Shared so that all might know they belong to a wider community than just themselves.
That is part of what Paul is saying when he writes to the church in Rome, as well as to us. He was struggling with the mystery of belonging. An observant Jew, a persecutor of early Christians, and now the foremost evangelist, he struggles with a simple question. Considering what God has done in Jesus, how has that changed the relationship between God and his fellow Jews? In other words, who is inside now, who is outside. And perhaps more importantly, has God abandoned the Jews? Are the Gentiles now the new chosen people?
He wrestles with this issue of belonging in the part of the letter and concludes that is not so much theology as it is wide-eyed amazement: “God has imprisoned all in disobedience so that God may be merciful to all.”
Notice what Paul did with those words. He didn’t reduce the Jews to second-class citizenship. He didn’t elevate the Gentiles to superiority. He leveled the playing field. No one is number one. No one earns grace instead of others, no one deserves mercy more than another. The only thing we humans have in common is our need for that love we cannot create ourselves. And if everyone needs such grace, then no human gets to say who deserves it.
Which brings us face to face with one of the most unsettling stories about Jesus. He encounters a woman who needs him to listen. Her daughter is suffering. The mother is beyond desperation; needs something she cannot provide. And so, like so many others in the gospels, she cries out for help.
And Jesus doesn’t say a word. Not a single word. And as the silence stretches, the disciples step in with their impatience, “Send her away.” Three words which have echoed throughout human history.
Send them away. It is worth noticing how ordinary those words can sound. We may never actually say them out loud. Instead, we say things like, “That’s not really our responsibility.” Or “There are other people who can help.” Or “We have to think about our own needs first.” Or simply, “Someone needs to do something about them.”
Different words. Same instinct. Send them away.
The refugees. The immigrants. The homeless. The addicted. The ex-cons. The g**s. The transgender kids. The fill-in-the-blank in every generation, in every place. All those people who come with questions, with hope, for help which makes us uncomfortable. All those people who don’t fit into our well-planned, well-organized expectations of others. They are making too much noise. They want something. They take up too much space. Send them away.
That’s always the solution. Always the practical way of dealing with such folks. That is certainly what the disciples felt. After all, there are limits, there are expectations, there are traditions, there are the proper channels, proper ways of doing things. For goodness’ sake, there are boundaries.
But the Beloved Community of God has the annoying habit of ignoring the maps we draw, the lines we make, the rules we set.
The woman doesn’t care about such rules, lines, maps – she simply refuses to disappear. She kneels before Jesus and asks again. She instinctively trusts that compassion outweighs rejection. She believes that mercy has not spoken the final word.
And somehow, through this encounter on what has become holy ground, the disciples witness something larger than themselves.
This outsider, this woman, they had dismissively written off becomes the role model for faith. She becomes the teacher. The one everyone told to keep quiet becomes the person whose voice echoes down through the centuries. Maybe that is the quiet miracle in this story. God often sends us teachers we never intended to meet.
There is an old habit in us of deciding who can teach us before they ever open their mouths. We look at someone's age, their education, their clothes, their accent, their politics, their mistakes, their place in society—and before they have said a word, we have already decided whether they have anything to say to us.
And then, occasionally, someone slips past our defenses. A child says something at exactly the moment we needed to hear it. A stranger offers kindness when we expect indifference. Someone whose life seems completely different from ours tells us a story that suddenly sounds strangely like our own.
And we realize: I almost missed this.
Maybe that is what happened with the woman who came to Jesus. The disciples thought they knew who belonged. Jesus seemed willing to let the encounter unfold. And the person everyone else had dismissed became the teacher.
Sometimes the person we have placed at the edge of the circle is the very person God has placed there to teach us how to enlarge it. Sometimes they dress differently or talk in a strange accent. Maybe they do not support our candidates, maybe they have a past we cannot begin to imagine. Maybe they offer more questions than answers. Yet, if we pay careful attention, we will discover it is God speaking through them all this time.
God’s Beloved Community expands when we learn to listen, when we think we have every reason not to do so.
Isn’t that the way mercy has always worked?
We like the status quo, mercy surprises us.
We like symmetry, mercy offers generosity.
We like fairness, mercy pushes us toward compassion.
We like keeping score, mercy tears up the scorecard.
This doesn’t mean justice no longer matters. Not in the least. Mercy doesn’t ask us to pretend hurts never happen. Mercy is the means of healing. Justice tells the truth about our broken lives, ruined relationships, shattered dreams. While mercy will not let that brokenness become the final chapter in the story of our lives.
I wonder if that is why Jesus spent so much time around tables. For meals have a way of showing who we think belongs. Who is invited, and who is not.
Who is it that everyone cannot wait to see, and who is going to be merely tolerated. And perhaps most important, who sits where.
I remember seeing a table at a community meal where the chairs were not arranged in neat rows with certain people clustered together. They were simply mixed — old and young, people who knew one another and people who had never met, those who came to serve and those who came because they needed a meal. There was something almost theological about that ordinary arrangement of chairs. Because sometimes the first step toward belonging is simply having a place to sit.
A chair says: You don't have to stand outside. A place at the table says: We expected you. And an open seat says: There is room for you here.
So Jesus, being Jesus, kept rearranging the seating chart. Pulling out a place for tax collectors. Offering a seat for fishermen. Welcoming widows, children, religion experts, sinners. All those people burdened with regrets. All the ones full of questions. Folks who carried more shame than honor.
Time and again, Jesus kept setting more places at the table, turning it into a living parable of God’s great love for every person, for every people.
Imagine if God’s people saw themselves offering that table. Not because we are so perfect at hospitality, but because we have been offered it.
Every one of us has stories we are hesitant to tell, even to those that know us best.
Failures.
Disappointments.
Grief from long ago.
Those regrets which awaken us at 3 a.m.
None of us comes to the table with clean hands, but we can show up with open hands. Which is more than enough. Because grace doesn’t expect spotless lives, only open hearts.
You know as well as I do that our culture teaches us that our identity comes from drawing sharper lines.
But our gospel tells us that we discover who we are when we cross those lines.
We constantly are told there isn’t enough – love, compassion, resources, places where we can belong.
So we need to gate our communities, build higher walls.
Yet Jesus shows up with a different view of economics. An economy where forgiveness multiplies doesn’t diminish. Where compassion becomes ripples spreading through people’s lives. Where every blessing births more blessings. Where strangers are seen as neighbors and neighborhoods become communities.
Imagine what might happen in our lives, in our neighborhoods, in our world, if people described places of worship as the place where mercy has the last word.
Not because truth is ignored or people avoid those difficult conversations.
But because after truth has been spoken, after all mistakes are confessed, after all the hurts are recognized, after every tear is gathered to form the waters of baptism, mercy still has something to say.
Perhaps you have watched children at the ocean.
They spend hours carving out roads in the sand, building castles, forming walls, digging moats, and daring the water to try to advance. The lines and walls and moats matter to the kids. But not to the tide.
It doesn’t argue with the children, it does not shame them. It does not laugh at their efforts or insult them.
The water just keeps coming.
Wave after wave.
Slow, patient, determined, steady, faithful.
By the time the tide turns and begins heading back out, every castle, road, moat, wall, line is gone.
Not because the water was angry, but because that is what the ocean does. It reaches farther than we imagined.
Maybe God’s mercy is like that.
We spend our lives drawing lines, building walls, putting up barriers both seen and unspoken. This person belongs, but not that one. Cousin Millie deserves grace, but no way does Uncle Joe. We will open the door to that neighbor, but the newcomer can wait outside.
While all the time, God’s mercy keeps coming. Slow, patient, determined, steady, faithful. Until that day, when we realize that all those walls, all those barriers, all those lines, all those standards, all those distinctions we thought were carved in stone, had been washed away.
Not by force, but by love.
And we find ourselves standing on the shore, on the edge of that crystal sea in God’s Beloved Community, realizing that what Isaiah promised, what the psalmist sang, what Paul wrote, and what Jesus reveals is true.
God is still gathering.
The table is still expanding.
The invitation is still being offered.
And mercy always has the final word.