04/06/2025
Theodore McCarrick passed away. May God have mercy on his soul. I just re-read a homily I delivered on the Sunday after the news broke about his involvement in sexual abuse in 2018. I have decided to post it here now, as I think the message is worth re-visiting.
******************************************
I often hear in the business world: “If you want to have an ownership interest in the company, you have to have some skin in the game.” The idea is that if you have made a tangible investment in the company, you will work harder for the company's success.
You are the Catholic Church. You, the people in the pews, have skin in this game. You have skin and bones, a heart and a brain in this game. You have your soul, your very self, invested in this enterprise we call the Catholic Church. You have served by your presence; you have served by your ministry. You have made financial contributions on a regular basis. You are not a spectator or an employee. You are doing service to the Church right now. Your ministry of presence is a loud, bold proclamation that this is your Church. I am proud to be a part of the same organization that you are part of. I am proud to be Catholic.
There have been terrible crimes committed against our Church by people within our Church – in fact, by some of our leaders. The impact of this has been devastating to the direct victims and demoralizing to all of us. Just about all of us are very hurt and angry. Although our anger is justified, we should not allow our anger to create any further division among ourselves. The divisions that have already resulted from these crimes are battles won by the primary enemy of the Church - Satan. Division is one of his primary tactics. Our counterattack must be determined unity. We need to remember in all of this, that Jesus is Our Lord and we must always act with His will in mind. Our goals should be justice and peace and healing and unity. With that in mind, I would like to share with you something I read online this week. It is taken from something written recently by a Catholic Priest and I quote:
“These past days as I moved from the rectory to the church, from the halls of the nursing homes and hospitals, as I’ve passed out school supplies to numerous neighborhood youth, I’ve had this one thought, “Take the collar off.”
This morning, I didn’t want to put my collar on. I was ashamed. I was tired. I was angry. I didn’t want to be painted with a stained brush. But I did (put the collar on). Then later, as I visited sick parishioners in the hospital, I walked by a woman standing outside a room. As I continued to the elevator, she came up from behind, asking if I was a Catholic priest. I was ready to take the hit… but as I turned and said “Yes,” she asked, with tears in her eyes, if I would anoint her brother who was dying with cancer.
No matter what I have thought about the collar these past few days, she saw it as a sign of hope and of the presence of Christ. If I decided not to wear it, her brother would not have received the sacrament he needed and her entire family might not have experienced comfort.
The collar is not about me. It is about Jesus Christ. It is about us remembering that we are not journeying alone in this world… I am certainly unworthy to wear it, but I realize I’m called to wear it, not for myself, but for the sake of others. As I put it on, I now must remember to ask God’s help to grow into a holy priest of God, a bridge and not an obstacle.” (End quote)
This priest is suffering to his very core, but he bravely took ownership of his vocation and mission. As a person who has spent close to 60 years of his life as a baptized Catholic layperson, I am now in the position of being an ordained Catholic clergyman. I am making an appeal to you - not as a Catholic clergyman or as a former layperson but simply as your brother in Christ. I am not asking you to look the other way. Quite the contrary - I am asking you to recognize your rights and responsibilities as an owner of this Church. Your rights and responsibilities in this Church are codified in the Code of Canon Law – specifically, Canon 204 through Canon 231. You can find this on the internet. If you search for “Code of Canon Law” and add the keywords “People of God”, you should find a link to the Vatican website. I implore you to do so.
Here is a partial selection, which addresses your rights and responsibilities. I quote from canon 212:
“§2. The Christian faithful are free to make known to the pastors of the Church their needs, especially spiritual ones, and their desires.
§3. … they have the right and even at times the duty to manifest to the sacred pastors their opinion on matters which pertain to the good of the Church and to make their opinion known to the rest of the Christian faithful.”
In addition to the Code of Canon Law, the Catechism of the Catholic Church has a lot to say on the topic of the mission, rights and responsibilities of the laity. You can also find the Catechism online. Again, I ask you to educate yourself on this.
If you have needs that you want to make known to your pastors, if you have an opinion on any matter which pertains to the good of the Church, you have a right and even at times a duty to express these needs and opinions. Your voice can and, at times, must be heard. If you would like to express your opinion to me, contact me and I will take it very seriously. I don’t have all of the answers right now. I don’t know that anyone else has all of the answers right now. But I do believe that all of us, together, can and will do what is necessary to heal our Church. A greater level of open communication involving the entire body of Christ is an important first step, in my opinion. So let’s at least start with that and go from there. Jesus can calm the waters of any storm. Let’s keep our focus on Him and ask Him for guidance.
Despite the sins and mistakes of some of our leadership, we should forgive them. It’s a part of being Christian – maybe the most difficult part. That may take us a long time. But we need to honestly try. Remember, when we forgive others, we also heal ourselves.
Saint Paul said “If one member suffers, all suffer together; if one member is honored, all rejoice together.” Right now, we are suffering. Again, the direct victims of these crimes have suffered terribly. Our laity are suffering and our clergy are suffering. Let’s pray for healing for the victims. Let’s pray for each other. Also, the good priests of this parish could use your prayers and expressions of kindness.
Today’s Gospel tells us of a time of controversy among the disciples of Jesus. A different type of controversy, certainly, but there is a similarity. Many people found what they were hearing to be shocking and many left Jesus. Again, I am not equating the circumstances but rather the fact that there was a test of faith involved. Jesus challenged His chosen ones - He asked them, "Do you also want to leave?"
Today, we face a challenge. Our faith is being tested. This is a wake-up call. This may even get worse before it gets better. But I am not going anywhere. This is our house, our home. We all need to be willing to roll up our sleeves and get to work, in unity, with love and forgiveness, as our master, Jesus, would have us do. It’s time for every Catholic who loves this Church as you do and as I do, lay persons and clergy, to claim ownership. We all have the right and the responsibility for protecting our home, from both internal and external threats - for the safety and the material and spiritual welfare of our children and our children’s children and our children’s children’s children. We owe that to them. That is a sacred duty we have. After Hurricane Sandy’s destruction, a slogan was born: “Jersey Strong.” We are in a storm of a different kind right now. It’s time for us to be “Catholic Strong.” If I were the last Catholic on earth, they’d have to carry me out of here in a body bag because I am not leaving HIM. And I’m not leaving you, either. Jesus has the words of eternal life. We have come to believe and are convinced that He is the Holy One of God. To whom shall we go?
God bless you.