07/27/2026
Ch-ch-ch-Changes
I want to begin this morning with a single verse — a strange, almost hidden line tucked at the end of Jesus’ parables in Matthew 13. Jesus says:
“Therefore every scribe who has become a disciple in the kingdom of heaven is like the master of a household who brings out of his treasure what is new and what is old.”
Or as David Bowie once put it, “Turn and face the strange.”
That’s not bad advice for disciples. Because the kingdom of heaven is always breaking in from the edges, always arriving in ways that unsettle our assumptions.
But it is also a strange line, because scribes are usually the target of Jesus’ criticism. They are the guardians of a faith tradition grown stale, rigid, and overly confident in its own correctness. They are the ones who, in Jesus’ telling, have allowed the living Word of God to calcify into a system of human desires, human fears, and human control. They are the ones who mistake tradition for truth, and habit for holiness. Jesus says the scribe who becomes a disciple learns to face that strangeness — to welcome the newness God is bringing, even when it disrupts the comfort of the old. The scribe’s work shifts from guarding tradition to discerning the Spirit, from preservation to imagination, from nostalgia to holy curiosity.
In today’s gospel, Jesus imagines a scribe who becomes a disciple — a scribe who undergoes conversion. A scribe who moves from defending the past to discerning the future. A scribe whose job description changes from preservation to imagination, from gatekeeping to openness, from protecting what once was to attending to what God is doing now.
Jesus says such a scribe becomes like the master of a household who brings out treasures both old and new. Not old instead of new. Not new instead of old. But both — held together, discerned together, offered together.
This is the image I want us to hold today, because it speaks directly to the moment the church finds itself in. We are living at a juncture in history where nostalgia is tempting, decline is real, and the future is uncertain. And yet the Spirit is speaking. The kingdom is breaking in. The treasure room is filling up — but it requires wisdom to know what to preserve, what to release, and what to embrace.
Our first reading from 1 Kings gives us Solomon, newly crowned, overwhelmed, aware of his limitations. God invites him to ask for anything. Solomon does not ask for the glory days of David. He does not ask for military strength or political stability. He asks for a listening heart— lev shomea — a heart tuned to God’s voice.
This is the posture of the scribe‑disciple. Not a heart clinging to the past, nor a heart chasing novelty for novelty’s sake, but a heart listening for God’s wisdom in a changing world.
The church needs Solomon’s prayer now more than ever. Because decline is not simply a crisis; it is a revelation. It reveals where our assumptions were misplaced. It reveals where our forms served a moment but cannot serve this one. It reveals where we have confused the Gospel with the way we used to do things.
Powdered wigs had their moment. So did certain church structures, certain expectations, certain cultural privileges. They served their time. But that time is not coming back. And that is not a failure — it is an invitation to wisdom.
The psalmist says, “When your word is opened, it gives light and understanding.” Notice the verb: opened. The Word is not a museum artifact. It is not a relic to be preserved behind glass. It is something that unfolds, illuminates, reveals.
Sola Scriptura is not a call to freeze the church in amber. It is a call to let Scripture continually open us to God’s living voice. And Scripture, when opened, often shines light on places we would rather not look — our assumptions, our fears, our nostalgia.
And we’ve seen this time and time again in Scripture, how the Spirit speaks through the outsider, often, through the unexpected voice, the one who stands outside our assumptions. Mary outside the tomb and the first evangelist. The Samaritan Woman at the Well. And Paul, the out-of-control persecutor to chief operating officer of The Way. The Word gives light — but the Spirit gives direction. And sometimes that direction comes from the margins.
Paul’s soaring words in Romans 8 remind us that the stability of the church does not come from its institutions, its traditions, or its attendance numbers. It comes from the unbreakable love of God in Christ Jesus.
Nothing can separate us from that love — not decline, not cultural shifts, not the loss of familiar forms, not the death of old assumptions. The Spirit intercedes in our weakness — not in our strength, not in our certainty, but in our vulnerability.
This is exactly where the church is right now: weak, uncertain, humbled. And therefore — paradoxically — open. Open to the Spirit’s intercession. Open to the kingdom’s surprise. Open to the new treasure God is bringing forth.
The parables Jesus tells in Matthew 13 are not about institutional preservation. They are about divine surprise.
The kingdom is like:
- a mustard seed — tiny, disruptive, invasive
- leaven — hidden, transformative, impossible to control
- treasure in a field — found by accident
- a pearl — requiring the surrender of everything else
- a net — gathering all kinds, not just the familiar kinds
These are not images of a tradition that stays the same. These are images of a kingdom that grows, expands, disrupts, surprises, and demands change.
The kingdom is not a museum. It is a living, growing reality.
So what does it mean for us — here, now — to be scribe‑disciples who bring out treasures old and new?
It means honoring the old treasures that still serve the Gospel:
the sacraments, the Scriptures, the call to love our neighbor, the rhythms of prayer, the wisdom of generations.
It means releasing the old treasures that no longer serve the Gospel:
the assumptions that church should look like it did in 1955, or 1965 or even pre-covid; the belief that faithfulness equals familiarity, the habits that comfort us but do not transform us.
And it means embracing the new treasures God is giving us:
new voices, new forms of community, new ways of worship, new understandings of mission, new partnerships, new imagination.
The scribe‑disciple is not nostalgic.
The scribe‑disciple is not reckless.
The scribe‑disciple is wise — Solomon’s listening heart, Psalm 119’s opened Word, Romans 8’s inseparable love, Matthew’s surprising kingdom.
The church’s decline is not solved by sentimentality. It is addressed by wisdom — the courage to see clearly, repent honestly, and imagine boldly.
We fool ourselves with pretty nostalgia. We imagine that if we just try hard enough, we can recreate what once was. But the Spirit is not calling us backward. The Spirit is calling us forward — into a future where the kingdom is breaking in through mustard seeds, leaven, outsiders, and unexpected voices.
The question for the church is not:
“How do we get back what we had?”
but
“What is the Spirit bringing forth now?”
Imagine the scribe‑disciple standing at the threshold of a storeroom — shelves lined with scrolls, artifacts, memories — and also a table where new tools, new maps, new instruments are being crafted.
The disciple reaches for both.
Not because both are equal,
but because both are needed for the journey.
The kingdom is a storeroom with a future.
And we — by God’s grace — are invited to be scribe‑disciples who listen, discern, and bring out treasures old and new, for the sake of the Gospel and for the sake of the world God loves.
Amen.