01/25/2026
Letter to the Editor by Michael Armer
When ICE was an outfit we could be proud of.
Once upon a time, I had a guy deported.
I was helping run a foreign exchange program in support of the Irish peace process. The several hundred participants were almost all in their early 20s, and as my old gym teacher used to encourage us to lock our lockers, “Boys, if you put 10 people in a room, one of them will be a crook.”
This young man was more than a crook. While in the program, he committed and was convicted of felony assault of two people. By the time he was released from jail, he had overstayed the visa that allowed him to participate in the program. I recall driving him to the airport and making sure the airplane door shut behind his sorry derriere.
We had quite a few visa overstays. What was especially frustrating was that our program staff could tell federal immigration enforcement, then part of the Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS), exactly where our overstays lived and worked. Regrettably, INS simply didn’t have enough staff to pick them up and get them out of the country. The only way INS could help us with overstays was if a program participant was a felon.
Bingo — now we had a way to get him out of the country.
The INS enforcement officers were from the part of INS we now know as ICE, Immigration and Customs Enforcement. I was the exchange program’s point of contact with the INS, and the enforcement officers were very professional. There was never any question of conduct unbecoming an officer.
It is no exaggeration to say that many ICE officers seen on TV these days display the polar opposite of that professionalism.
Failure to clearly identify themselves, excessively violent actions, unnecessary face masks, failure to show legally valid authorization, transporting people to foreign countries without a hearing, and the detention of U.S. citizens are wrong on so many levels. Now, an ICE agent shot and killed a Minneapolis woman. My view is that this shooting was an unjustified blunder by an agent who disregarded responsible law-enforcement firearm discipline. I have seen firsthand how our immigration system can responsibly remove dangerous people who are here illegally — but responsible is not what ICE is about these days.
link (paywalled):
The following is a letter to the editor submitted by a reader and does not reflect the views of the Pioneer. Letters can be sent to [email protected] or P.O. Box 455, Bemidji, MN 56601.