09/06/2026
Sometimes church feels…heavy. And I don’t mean the good kind of heavy where you walk through the doors carrying everything that happened that week and somehow leave remembering that God is still God and you were never actually expected to hold the entire universe together yourself. I mean the kind where following Jesus starts feeling suspiciously like there is a clipboard somewhere with your name on it. Did you attend enough? Serve enough? Read your Bible enough? Pray enough? Volunteer enough? Are you joyful enough while doing all of those things? And somewhere in there it can become really easy to feel like you also need to look like you have this whole Christianity thing reasonably under control. Struggles are allowed, obviously, but preferably the kind from five years ago that have already been resolved, taught you an important lesson, and can now be turned into a testimony with three points and an encouraging Bible verse. Walking into church and saying, “Actually, I’m struggling with God right now and I have absolutely no idea how this story ends,” is considerably more uncomfortable.
Because sometimes it feels like we aren’t supposed to say, “I’m having a hard time believing this.” Or, “I read that part of the Bible and I have questions.” Or, “I have prayed about this for years and nothing has changed, and I’m actually pretty angry about it.” We know what the correct Christian answer is supposed to sound like, so sometimes we give that answer even when it isn’t remotely what is happening inside us. We walk through the doors, smile, say we’re doing good, sing the songs, know when to stand and sit, and generally give the impression that Sunday morning began with peaceful prayer and reflection instead of whatever minor catastrophe actually occurred five minutes before we arrived.
And then somebody asks, “How are you?”
“Good.”
Because apparently that is the answer.
Meanwhile, if I answered that question completely truthfully on any given Sunday, it might be more along the lines of, “Well, I got five hours of sleep, one calf has diarrhea, another one is breathing in a way I don’t appreciate, I have manure somewhere on me but have decided not to investigate exactly where, I’m worried about six things I can’t control, I prayed about three of them while driving here, I’m currently having a theological disagreement with God about at least one of them, and I am running primarily on caffeine, stubbornness, and the sustaining grace of Jesus. But yeah. Good. How are you?”
Which is probably why we just say “good.”
And that’s funny until you realize how often we do the exact same thing with the things that aren’t funny. Sometimes “good” means I don’t know how to explain what’s happening. Sometimes it means I don’t know if this is a safe place to tell the truth. Sometimes it means if I actually start talking about this right now, there is a nonzero chance I’m going to cry in the church foyer and neither of us has budgeted enough time for that before the service starts. So we say good, they say good, everyone is apparently doing remarkably well, and we all proceed into the sanctuary carrying things nobody else knows about.
I know a little about what happens when church starts feeling like one more thing you are failing at, because there was a stretch when my attendance was…not exactly impressive. In my case, a lot of it was calves. Apparently nobody informed the calves that Sunday morning was the Sabbath, because they continued getting sick, needing fed, developing diarrhea, escaping, breathing suspiciously, and occasionally attempting to meet Jesus personally at exactly the same rate seven days a week. A Jersey calf does not care that church starts in forty-five minutes. She has never read Hebrews. If she decides 9:12 Sunday morning is the perfect time for a 105-degree fever while another one has somehow gotten her head somewhere anatomically unreasonable, congratulations, this is your Sunday morning now. Jesus talked about getting the ox out of the ditch on the Sabbath, and those of us who work with livestock understand that sometimes the ox is not only in the ditch, but has apparently invited three friends and somebody knocked over something on the way there.
So yes, I missed church. Sometimes quite a bit. And believe me, I knew. I was there for the part where I wasn’t there. Then eventually I got a letter from church about my attendance and what could happen if I didn’t start coming regularly again. Except it wasn’t just a letter. It came certified mail. It had to be signed for. And somehow that little detail made the whole thing hit differently, because certified mail has a certain level of seriousness to it. Certified mail is what you send when you want proof that somebody received something. It feels legal. Official. Important. And there is something rather surreal about certified mail from your church and then opening it to discover that, yes, they have noticed you haven’t been there enough.
And the thing is, they weren’t wrong. I hadn’t been there enough. I’m not going to rewrite history and pretend my attendance was wonderful and everyone else was completely unreasonable. Church matters. Being around other Christians matters. But I already knew I hadn’t been there. I already felt guilty about it. I already felt stretched thin and like I wasn’t doing enough in several different directions at once. I wasn’t trying to walk away from Jesus. I wasn’t sitting at home on Sunday mornings defiantly eating pancakes and announcing my rejection of organized religion. I was taking care of calves. I was working. I was tired. I was trying. And when that certified letter arrived, instead of feeling like somebody had noticed that I was missing, it felt like somebody had noticed that my attendance was missing.
That distinction has stuck with me, because what I needed probably wasn’t a certified letter telling me there could be consequences if I didn’t come back. I needed somebody to ask, “Hey, we haven’t seen you much lately. Are you doing okay?” And yeah, had I answered truthfully, they might have gotten the entire calf-health report, several unrelated thoughts, an explanation of why I was running on five hours of sleep, and possibly a theological question nobody was prepared to discuss in the church parking lot. But at least the question would have been about me not my attendance. I needed to feel missed, not monitored. Instead, I remember holding something from my church that was official enough to require a signature and wondering whether I even wanted to walk through those doors again.
And yeah, I switched my membership elsewhere. I didn’t leave Jesus. I didn’t decide church didn’t matter. I didn’t abandon Christianity. I just eventually realized that staying somewhere because I felt guilty about leaving probably wasn’t the same thing as belonging there, and there are times when finding another healthy church is not walking away from the body of Christ. Sometimes it is how you remain part of it.
Maybe your version has absolutely nothing to do with calves or certified mail. Maybe you missed because you were exhausted. Maybe you were caring for someone. Maybe getting yourself and a newborn out the door before church should qualify as a minor miracle and somebody should be documenting it for possible inclusion in Acts. Maybe you work Sundays. Maybe your marriage was struggling and sitting together pretending everything was fine felt worse than staying home. Maybe anxiety makes walking through those doors much harder than anyone realizes. Maybe somebody at church said something that hurt you and they probably don’t even remember saying it. Maybe you asked a question and quickly discovered that people were considerably more comfortable when you already knew the answer. Or maybe you never stopped attending at all. Maybe you have been sitting in the same pew every Sunday, answering “good” every time someone asks how you are because you’re not entirely sure what would happen if one Sunday you finally said, “Actually, I’m not.”
Because you can love Jesus and still have questions. You can trust God and still have days when you don’t understand Him at all. You can believe the Bible is the Word of God and still reach a passage and think, “Okay, Lord, we are going to need to discuss this one.” You can pray faithfully and wonder why God seems silent. You can sing “It Is Well With My Soul” while your soul would currently like to submit a formal objection. You can know that God is good and still be angry about something He allowed. Faith and struggle are not opposites, and Scripture would be considerably shorter if they were. David asked God where He was. Job questioned. Jeremiah complained. Elijah reached a point where he was simply done. Thomas wanted evidence. Peter confidently announced what he would absolutely never do and then proceeded to do exactly that three times before breakfast. God could have cleaned all of that up before putting these people in Scripture. He didn’t.
And maybe that is something churches need to remember, especially when we look at how many young adults eventually disappear. Barna has reported that 64% of young adults with a church background dropped out of regular church involvement at some point during young adulthood, and Lifeway Research found that 66% of young adults who regularly attended Protestant churches as teenagers stopped attending regularly for at least a year between ages 18 and 22. That doesn’t mean two-thirds stopped believing in God, and plenty eventually returned, but two out of three is still a number that should bother us. Maybe instead of only asking why young adults are leaving church, we also need to ask whether they felt like they could tell us they were struggling before they left. Could they ask the uncomfortable question without everyone panicking? Could they admit they were angry with God? Could they say, “I don’t know what I believe about this right now”? Could they admit that life was falling apart without suddenly feeling like they had become somebody’s spiritual repair project?
And no, this doesn’t mean accountability disappears. Church attendance matters. Christian community matters. Hebrews 10:25 remains inconveniently present in my Bible and I have checked. Sometimes loving someone really does mean telling them something they don’t want to hear. But accountability should make it safer to tell the truth, not more necessary to hide it. There is a difference between saying, “I see you struggling, let me walk beside you,” and, “I see you struggling, could you please struggle in a way that looks slightly more Christian?”
Because when I look at Jesus, I see Him moving toward people everyone else already had opinions about. The woman at the well had enough personal history to keep a church gossip chain occupied for the foreseeable future. Zacchaeus had some creative accounting practices. Thomas had questions. Peter was…Peter. And then there was the thief on the cross, who had absolutely no time left to get his act together. No improved attendance record. No Bible study. No volunteering. No opportunity to repair his reputation or spend six months proving that his conversion was genuine. He had nothing impressive to hand Jesus. All he could say was, essentially, “Remember me.”
And Jesus gave him paradise.
Church is made entirely out of humans, which explains quite a bit. Churches are going to get things wrong. Christians are going to get things wrong. I am absolutely going to get things wrong, and there is probably enough evidence already available for somebody to compile The Collected Things Erica Probably Should Have Thought About Five More Minutes. But the people who represent Jesus imperfectly are not Jesus Himself. Someone can misunderstand you without God misunderstanding you. Someone can be uncomfortable with your questions while God already knows every question you were afraid to say out loud. Someone can look at your empty seat and make assumptions without knowing what you were carrying while that seat was empty.
So maybe we need to make more room in church for people who don’t have it all together. Room for questions that don’t get neatly resolved by the end of Bible study. Room for someone to admit that they are angry with God and still sit beside us next Sunday. Room for the person who hasn’t been there in three months to walk back through the doors without feeling like they owe everyone a defense. Room for someone to answer “How are you?” with “Actually, not good,” and have us be willing to hear the answer. Room for faith that currently feels less like a mustard seed and more like you are reasonably certain there was a mustard seed around here somewhere, but it may have rolled under the couch.
Because Jesus didn’t say, “Come to Me once you look like you have this figured out.” He said, “Come to me, all who labor and are heavy laden, and I will give you rest.”
And I keep thinking about that one missing sheep. The Shepherd noticed it was gone. But He didn’t send the sheep certified mail telling it to improve its attendance.
He went looking for it.
Maybe sometimes the best way to bring somebody back isn’t to remind them that they should be there.
Maybe it’s to make sure they know somebody actually noticed that they were gone.
girl