10/26/2026
October 26, 2026
Strategic Discipleship, Chapter 2, Discipleship Basics
What Counts As “Fruit” and What Does Not (Part 1)
The simplest understanding of the functional role of Fruit is, “Fruit is proof of Life.” It manifests in the three forms we have just listed as who we are (character/transformation/salvation), what we do (good works), and in what kingdom we claim citizenship (sanctification from this world system)—i.e., being, doing, and serving. Why do we say that? Because Jesus told us in John 15:4-5 that He is the Source of fruit and without Him we can do nothing. Add to that concept the fact that when we abide in the Vine, fruit is always produced, and its presence constitutes proof of abiding. Romans 5:9-10 confirms that it is the Life of Christ as a transformation process that saves us, and that is the “Life more abundantly” that He promised by His coming (John 10:10). Of course, the Life we are addressing is spiritual Life, not physical, biological life. In the physical/biological life sense, a person can be alive and yet still be found to be healthy or unhealthy. In the spirit, the same healthy/unhealthy designations apply. Jesus said, “Without Me you can do nothing”; He did not say, “Without Me you cease to exist.” Obviously, those who do not even know Christ still do things in the sense of “having activity,” so Jesus’ meaning has to be “You can do nothing as you ought to do it to be valuable in and to the Kingdom.” He did also say, however, that there are good and bad trees, and some bad may be found where we expect the good to be and the bad trees not to be (Matthew 13:24-30). So, “You will know them by their fruit” simultaneously promotes the same message as Paul’s 1 Corinthian 11:19 statement, “For there must also be factions among you, that those who are approved may be recognized among you.” “Those who are approved may be recognized” is tantamount to saying “You will know them by their fruits [i.e., “the fruit of their conduct of faith,” our paraphrase].” So, by the “Those Who Are Approved May Be Recognized Principle,” simultaneously, fruit is “Proof of Life.”
People, especially believers, are sometimes very keen to live in a fantasy world concerning their own “goodness” (i.e., Proverbs 20:6, “Most men will proclaim each his own goodness, but who can find a faithful man?”). But the proof of actual Life (by the higher definition)—and especially, abundant Life—in the realm of Spirit is the presence or absence of Fruit of the Spirit in the form that God determines to be acceptable and useful. That means that the subset of “useful and genuine fruit” is smaller than is often claimed, either by the church or by the world in general. The foregoing overestimation of “goodness” and “fruitfulness” is “fudging” our behavior based on our intentions or deception, not our actual performance. But a believer cannot “fudge” real fruit. He/She can attempt to redefine what is “good” and “bad” fruit (Genesis 3:5), they can encourage and reinforce each other’s bad fruit by calling it good, they can claim that fruit doesn’t really matter, only “faith.” But however we attempt to twist and spin reality, fruit is proof of connection; and connection is proof of healthy relationship. First and foremost, connection is proof of invested trust. In Chapter 4, we will discuss our trust placed by a situation by situation, choice by choice act of our will as the connection point—“joint,” if you will—that anchors and maintains our Abid-ing in the Vine status. Not all that call Jesus “Lord, Lord” will enter into the Kingdom, only those known by Him (Matthew 7:21-23), and not all “crops” growing in His field are good plants from good seed (Matthew 13:24-30). By the same token/reference, not all that appears as religious fruit will count “in that Day” (the Day of Christ, or Judgment Seat of Christ) as reward credentials. False/Fake fruit abounds in religion, but not in the Kingdom—that is one of the primary designators between Real and apparent, activity and lasting effect, gold/silver/precious stones and chaff, perishable and lasting, knowing/being known and religious obscurity. Without fruit—the fruit He designates—there is no proof, only presumption; and presumption is another term for “You will be like God knowing good and evil” deception.
One of the staple features of a 1950s-1980s household as I was growing up was a large bowl of wax fruit on some table somewhere in the house, and the fake fruit was almost indistinguishable from the real thing! It was beautiful, decorative, pristine. But its real appeal was that it was non-spoiling, non-deteriorating, perpetually-perfect adornment for the perfect home. Purchased once, it never had to be refreshed or replaced. It was the appearance of fruit without the messy downsides. It is true that it did not decay, but neither would it sustain life, only the appearance of life. Fool’s gold has no value, but it sparkles and looks good. Wax fruit has frequently been mistaken for the real thing (not so much the plastic copy of fruit—that’s just weird!), but has only decorative, non-substantive value. Try to take even one bite and the coun-terfeit is exposed. The fake is often preferable to the real in some homes because it is low maintenance. Real ministry is often real-ly (pun intended) messy. In our usurped sovereignty, one of the delusions from which we suffer is that we have the prerogative to determine real and false, valuable and not valuable, “for me” or “not for me.” It is the same motivation working in King Saul when Samuel confronted him about his disobedience to the word of the Lord, and Saul was more concerned about his “street cred” than his under-performance. “OK, OK, Samuel, you got me. But at least allow me to save face in front of the people and keep up appearances.” (1 Samuel 15:24-25, my paraphrase). It is difficult to imagine that Saul could claim with a straight face to have obeyed (right to Samuel’s face, 1 Samuel 15:20). “I DID obey…but the people” was Saul’s compromised position, and he had to know that his fudging of God’s command conveyed through Samuel was not real obedience and was therefore not real fruit. It is equally difficult to imagine that somewhere down deep inside the “many” of Matthew 7:21-23 did not have an inkling that their ministry was off-target. But then, again, it is only “In [His] light that we see light” (Psalm 36:9), so when wandering in the darkness, and when all the religious agree on the “way church is done,” it is not difficult to miss that what you are producing by your religious activity is not the real thing. One of the stunning aspects of Matthew 7:21-23 is that the “many” petitioning Jesus “in that day” were completely taken off guard that their good works failed to meet His criterium of “known.” That is a very sobering statement that should be the point of focused assessment and for our own heart motivation. It is shocking to our system of belief when our production equals our definition of success, and yet both are “weighed in the balances and found wanting” (Daniel 5:27).