06/07/2026
One Truth, Many Voices
A sermon preached by the Rev. J. Thomas Buchanan on June 7, 2026
Covenant Presbyterian Church
22 “Fellow Israelites, listen to what I have to say: Jesus of Nazareth, a man attested to you by God with deeds of power, wonders, and signs that God did through him among you, as you yourselves know— 23 this man, handed over to you according to the definite plan and foreknowledge of God, you crucified and killed by the hands of those outside the law. 24 But God raised him up, having released him from the agony of death, because it was impossible for him to be held in its power. 25 For David says concerning him,
‘I saw the Lord always before me,
for he is at my right hand so that I will not be shaken;
26 therefore my heart was glad, and my tongue rejoiced;
moreover, my flesh will live in hope.
27 For you will not abandon my soul to Hades
or let your Holy One experience corruption.
28 You have made known to me the ways of life;
you will make me full of gladness with your presence.’
29 “Fellow Israelites, I may say to you confidently of our ancestor David that he both died and was buried, and his tomb is with us to this day. 30 Since he was a prophet, he knew that God had sworn with an oath to him that he would put one of his descendants on his throne. 31 Foreseeing this, David[d] spoke of the resurrection of the Messiah, saying,
‘He was not abandoned to Hades,
nor did his flesh experience corruption.’
32 “This Jesus God raised up, and of that all of us are witnesses.33 Being therefore exalted at the right hand of God and having received from the Father the promise of the Holy Spirit, he has poured out this that you see and hear.”
(Acts 2:22-33, NRSV)
When the Church tells the story of Pentecost, we usually begin – as we did! – with the spectacle of it all: the sound like the rush of a violent wind, the divided tongues as of fire, the bewildered crowd hearing the mighty works of God in the languages of far-flung places. Parthians, Medes, Elamites, residents of Mesopotamia, Judea, Cappadocia, Pontus and Asia, Egypt and Libya, Rome and Crete and Arabia — all of them hearing, in their own native tongues, the good news of God.
As we experienced two weeks ago, it’s a scene of holy bewilderment – the people don’t know what to make of it. Some are amazed. Some are perplexed. Some are dismissive. Some assume the whole morning can be explained away by saying that the disciples have simply declared that it’s 5 o’clock somewhere!
And the truth is, even the disciples themselves are wondering, as surprised as anyone else by what has come over them. They had been waiting, as Jesus told them to wait. They had been praying. But I doubt any of them had a strategic plan for this. I doubt Peter woke up that morning and said, “Well, by lunchtime, I’ll be preaching my first sermon.”
But then Peter does stand. The same Peter who had denied Jesus and run away … the same Peter whose courage had collapsed under pressure, now raises his voice and speaks. And from within this great explosion of sound and difference, one clear witness begins to take shape.
That’s where our scripture text begins today. Peter turns to the crowd and says, “Jesus of Nazareth, a man attested to you by God with deeds of power, wonders, and signs … this man, handed over according to the definite plan and foreknowledge of God, you crucified and killed by the hands of those outside the law. But God raised him up.”
That’s the center. That’s the claim from which everything else flows. Jesus lived among us as the presence and power of God. Human violence did what human violence does. The powers of this world tried to silence him, shame him, and bury him. But God raised him up. Death could not hold him. The crucified one is risen. The rejected one is Lord of all.
Now, it’s important for us to say with care that Peter’s words are not permission for Christians to turn accusation outward, as though the cross were the fault of some other people over there, long ago. Peter is speaking from within his own people, and the cross exposes something much wider and deeper than one crowd or one people. The cross tells the truth about what the world does when love grows too free, when mercy reaches too far, when truth becomes too dangerous, when God’s reign threatens the arrangements we have come to accept as normal.
But the resurrection tells the still greater truth: that God is not finished when the world has done its worst. This is the great truth at the heart of the Church’s witness. Before all our denominations, before all our confessions, before all our buildings and committees and hymnals and seminaries, there’s this: Jesus Christ, crucified and risen, is Lord. In him, God has acted for the life of the world. In him, love has gone all the way down into death and come back bearing life. In him, the future of God has broken into the present.
That’s the truth those first disciples declared, and lived, and ultimately died for. And it’s the truth in which we walk now. But as we’ve seen, Pentecost insists that this one truth does not come to us in one voice only. It comes in many voices, many accents, many languages, many histories, many songs. The Spirit does not erase difference in order to create unity. The Spirit creates a unity large enough to hold difference, and still is creating and re-creating that unity today.
From the outside, the rich diversity of Christian traditions and theologies and rituals can make this global faith of ours look like a chaotic mess. There are Catholics and Orthodox, Baptists and Methodists, Presbyterians and Pentecostals, Episcopalians and Mennonites, contemplatives and revivalists, people who cross themselves and people who raise their hands, people who chant ancient prayers and people who sing praise choruses with a drum set and fog machine.
It can be dizzying to consider that the Catholic contemplative, the “frozen chosen” Presbyterian, and the holy roller Pentecostal all confess Jesus as Lord, though no one would ever confuse one with the other!
And naturally, when we talk about Christian unity, we emphasize what we hold in common. We say, rightly, that Jesus is the center. But as we have come to know, Pentecost does something more daring than that. Pentecost also teaches us to honor the differences — not to treat as threats to be managed, but as varied gifts through which the Spirit may speak.
This is not a lazy tolerance that flattens everything out and pretends all distinctions are unimportant. Real generosity of spirit does not require us to stop caring about truth. It asks us to care deeply enough about truth to recognize that none of us possesses the whole of it by ourselves.
We need voices other than our own. We need traditions other than our own. We need witnesses who have seen what we have not seen, suffered what we have not suffered, cherished what we have neglected, and learned to speak of God in a language that may at first sound strange to our ears.
Look, few people enjoy being Presbyterian as much as I do. I love the breadth and seriousness of our tradition. I love its insistence that faith is not opposed to reason, that loving God includes loving God with all our heart, all our soul, and all our mind. I love its grand vision of the sovereignty of God, its deep trust that grace is prior to all our striving, and its conviction that Christian faith is never merely private. At our best, we have long understood discipleship as public, communal, and transformative, a life lived before God for the sake of the world.
But my own faith has been stretched and enriched by sojourns among Christians whose languages of faith were different from the one into which I was born. From the evangelicals of my childhood and youth, I learned a passionate love and reverence for Scripture. Among Lutherans, I came to understand why so many cherish the doctrine of the real presence of Christ in the Eucharist. In Pentecostal spaces, I encountered a Spirit-driven passion that could melt some of my icier instincts, and among the Charismatics, I saw with my own eyes a deep trust that God still heals, still moves in the Church with power. Among Episcopalians, I came to appreciate the grammar of worship, and the dignity and richness of an ancient liturgy. And through the Catholic monastic tradition, I have learned something of the volumes that can be spoken in silence.
All these traditions, of course, have blind spots. But so does ours. And the gifts of all of them are real. And when we receive them with humility, they don’t make us less Presbyterian, or less rooted, or less clear about what we believe. They make us more generous, more attentive, more alive to the wideness of God’s work.
Pentecost tells us that the Spirit loves translation. The Spirit takes the one truth of Jesus Christ and lets it be spoken in all the tongues of the earth. And in a way, that’s part of what we will be exploring this summer in the 2026 edition of a worship series we call “Summer Saints.”
Now, let me be clear again about what we mean by that. We’re not saying that every person covered in this series is a Christian “saint” in the formal sense. Some are Christians. Some not so much. Some had complicated relationships with faith. Some were deeply shaped by the Church, while others stood at a distance from it, or saw with painful clarity some of its failures. But each of them, whether intended or not, may help us hear some echo of the truth of the gospel more clearly:
• Dolly Parton will help us think about joy, generosity, dignity, and the grace of turning one’s gifts outward for the good of others.
• Howard Thurman will lead us inward, toward the deep sanctuary of the soul, where prayer becomes strength and silence becomes courage for the work of justice.
• Jane Goodall will invite us into wonder and reverent attention, teaching us to see the living world not as background scenery for human ambition, but as fellow creation held in the care of God.
• John Lewis will remind us that faith sometimes has to put on its shoes and cross the bridge, that love in public may very well look like courage, discipline, and good trouble.
• The Beatles will let us listen again to the longing for love and belonging that runs through so much human life, while asking at the same time to what kind of love the gospel truly calls us.
• Toni Morrison will bring us to memory, belovedness, trauma, and truth, insisting that no community can become whole by forgetting what must be remembered.
• And Flannery O’Connor will close the series by reminding us that grace is not always gentle in the ways we expect. Sometimes it comes as disruption, as judgment, as the strange mercy that breaks open our illusions so that something true can finally begin.
These are some very different voices! Appalachian and English, scientific and contemplative, prophetic and literary, joyful and severe. They don’t say the same thing. They don’t see from the same angle. They don’t all belong neatly together.
But that, really, is exactly the point. If Pentecost is true, then the Church should not be surprised when the Spirit uses many voices to awaken us. We should expect that the truth of Christ, though one, will reach us through a diversity of testimony, song, silence, courage, beauty, lament, laughter, and the hard grace of being told the truth.
The danger, of course, in a series like this is that we make much of the witness to the neglect of the One to whom the witness points. But Peter doesn’t stand at Pentecost to make much of Peter. He stands to proclaim Jesus. The languages are many, but the gospel is one. The voices are many, but the living Christ is the center. And that will be our task this summer: to listen generously, to discern carefully, and to keep looking toward Jesus, the crucified and risen one, in whom all truth finally finds its home.
My friends, the Spirit is still speaking in languages we did not grow up knowing. The Spirit is still widening our hearing. The Spirit is still gathering scattered voices into one great fellowship of love.
And the promise of Pentecost is that, by God’s grace, we may yet learn to hear and live ever more fully into our purpose and destiny – to the glory of God! Amen.
For more information, check out our website! https://www.covpresat...