03/26/2024
For the first time in decades, I decided that I needed to send a Letter to the Editors of the WSJ. It is in response to an excellent editorial by Jillian Kay Melchior, which I link to in the comments.
To the Editors of the Wall Street Journal
Ms. Melchior has done a commendable job of refuting and exposing the errant claims of assaults upon religious liberty in Ukraine. She demonstrated remarkable restraint in refusing to ask the obvious questions like: Is Senator J. D. Vance (and his ilk) willfully ignorant or simply Putin sycophant functionaries? Her missive kept focus and dealt with essential facts.
Not every perspective could be considered in refuting what she exposed as a carefully orchestrated PR campaign of falsehood. Still, I dare to opine that a key metric of war-time religious liberty has been overlooked – a metric which shows that the purported victim institutions of the Ukrainian Orthodox Church have actually received questionably excessive favors granted by the Ukrainian government – perhaps as a mindful mechanism to balance the travails of their schismatic rift with the Moscow Patriarchate.
I have made three trips to Ukraine over the past 16 months to encourage the work of military chaplains in the area around Kherson. I, a Lutheran, have been privileged to minister alongside Orthodox, Baptist, Mennonite, and non-denominational clergy who were risking their lives in forward positions. Military chaplaincy is quite new in Ukraine and the formula for awarding “slots” to chaplains is dramatically and heavily biased toward Orthodox priests. In church growth parlance, we distinguish between adherents and active participants. Orthodoxy has far more adherents than they do active participants in Ukraine. Other denominations and traditions made dramatic headway in evangelization in the decades immediately after the collapse of the USSR. Those groups are now under-represented in the ranks of commissioned military chaplains.
Is this proof of religious discrimination? Hardly. It is evidence that under trying circumstances and a rapidly evolving religious culture, their government is moving forward as quickly as they can and some of the nuances and niceties are unaffordable when your civilian populace is under constant attacks from artillery, missiles, and drones. The mix of commissioned chaplains, certified volunteer chaplains, military tentmakers (and a few oddball foreign visitors) are endeavoring, in the best tradition of US military chaplaincies, to provide spiritual care for every soldier, sailor, and marine who seeks it.
Religious freedom should always be a concern and it will always require give and take. In the current context, it is clearly a false flag for those who lack the courage to state the real reasons that they are choosing the wrong side in a difficult war. The people of Ukraine deserve our prayers – and sufficient ammunition to keep up the fight!
The Rev. Dr. Brad Miller
ChurchTech Institute
1019 NE 5th ST, Ankeny, IA 50021