07/29/2025
This was a sad but interesting post by Pastor Richard Blue from 2023 Statistics on several of the Lutheran Church Bodies regarding the shortage of Ordained Pastors in the bodies named.
Actually the earliest Lutheran Church groupings in America began with Shortages of Ordained Pastors. Here is the Eastern US the Dutch Lutherans formed small Congregations in New Amsterdam (New York & New Jersey ) but couldn’t get Lutheran Pastors. They often had to make use of Dutch Reform Pastors or their own elected Lay leaders.
Then as the Palatine German Synod’s/ Ministerium formed and prior to their formation there were constant appeals to Europe for Pastors to be sent . the Hamburg Orthodox Lutheran Synod and the Halle Pietist Lutherans and even the Swedish Lutherans tried to respond but a terrible shortage of ordained Pastors remained . The Ministerium organized by Muhlenberg and the Pennsylvanians, New Yorkers and the Shenandoah Henkel’s in New Market Virginia of the Ministerium began to utilize Lay leaders with a sense of Calling to fo Ministry. They were referred to as “Catechists”. And many under the mentoring of Ordained Pastors would become Ordained Pastors.
Our little ELCM (Evangelical Lutheran Conference & Ministerium of North America, Inc) predates both LCMC and NALC. We are out of the Early Dutch Lutheran. German Palatine, Ministerium - Muhlenberg - Krauth - Henkel tradition. And we are small but have more Ordained Pastors than Congregations even though the number of our congregations has grown. Several of our Pastors are serving Mission Congregations that are not ELCM . We also have some of our Ordained Pastors Serving in Chaplaincy settings - Military and Hospital, etc. So even though we have more Ordained Pastors on our Roster than congregations we do not have enough Ordained Pastors to cover all of our congregations and we thus have replicated the early Ministerium praxis of installing Catechists or teams of Catechist in Congregations where we have no Pastors available . The Congregation’s Elect (Call) a Catechist and the President of our Synod or someone appointed by the President installs the duly elected Catechist(s) into ministry . We have been delighted with the Mission results . Several Congregations that were almost destroyed by Ordained Pastors have truly come alive and are solidly Biblical Confessional Lutheran . To date we have Ordained one of the men who began as a Catechist and he is the current Secretary of our ELCM.
So we believe we truly do not need to re-invent the Wheel. Our early American Lutheran Forbearer’s faced the same issues ( LC-MS faced the same in the early years) and today the replication of thise early solutions can be very helpful.
Really it was the same challenge in the early Church - The harvest was plentiful but the laborers were few - but the Church did not place its focus in the highly credentialed elite but in the Calling to Ministry by tiny congregations in conjunction with appointment in ministry by Tent Maker, Fisherman , Tax Collector, etc. Believers and Followers (the first Pastors) of Jesus.
Anyhow this is the approach we in ELCM have been following drawn from our Eastern Early Lutheran heritage and from the early Christian Church.