08/31/2026
Fr. Dan's homily this past Sunday:
I like to think of characters in the Bible in terms of their whole story arc, where they start and how they progress and where they finish, the way I might think of some of my favorite fictional characters. This isn’t to downplay the reality of the biblical characters, but to enhance the reality of the fictional. There’s something very real about the hobbits in the Lord of the Rings, or alien characters I watch in Star Trek, or the dogs in Bluey.
Everyone has a story arc, and the characters we read about in our readings today are very much in the middle of theirs. They are reluctant, or hesitant, or confused about God’s will for them, not having reached full understanding yet.
Jeremiah, for instance, did not get what he expected, when he was asked to be a prophet. He’s suffering; people hate him; he was put in the stocks for saying what God gave him to say: “Thus says the Lord…”.
And yet, if he refuses to go do his job, his role, as a prophet, it’s like he’s holding it in, like fire burning in his bones. He has to let it out. It’s his life’s calling; he must do it.
The same goes for Jesus today. He must fulfill his mission, even if it results in his death. And so he told his disciples this, and they got upset. Peter in particular starts to tell Jesus how it ought to go.
There’s a rule of thumb for New Testament characters: If you’re telling Jesus what to do, you’re in a bad spiritual space. Things are the wrong way round. Whenever that happens, it’s clear that they are not thinking as God thinks; they are not on the same spiritual wavelength. And I don’t mean asking for things, but telling Jesus what he should do. There’s a difference between asking and telling. We of course can ask for things, in prayer.
So, for instance, Martha tells Jesus to tell Mary to help her in the kitchen. And Jesus says, “No, Mary is where she needs to be, sitting at the teacher’s feet”. The mother of James and John asks Jesus to have them sit at his right and left in his kingdom, like princes. And Jesus says, “No one can ask for that; that has been planned by my Father”.
And in today’s reading, Peter tells Jesus “nothing so bad as that should ever happen to you!” Peter gets mad at Jesus for bringing up suffering. And Jesus gets mad at Peter for trying to avoid the suffering.
There’s always suffering. This is life. It’s not pretty, but we suffer all the time. We even sign up for suffering: we don’t know what the future brings, and that’s part of the reason we make the vows. Whatever happens, good times or bad, sickness or health, I go through it with you. And the other person says, whatever happens, good times or bad, sickness or health, I’ll go through it with you! And sometimes that ‘s not easy to fulfill.
Peter didn’t understand this yet, but he’s still in the middle of his story arc. He’s still learning who Jesus is and God’s ways. He certainly didn’t realize that to try to talk Jesus out of the cross is to be on the same wavelength as Satan. He sounds, inadvertently, just like the temptations Jesus experienced in the desert. Martha and the mother of James and John may not have been on the same wavelength as Jesus, but Peter, in this instance, was completely on the wrong wavelength, he was on the wavelength of Satan.
We can’t have Christianity without the cross, without suffering.
The alternative is to not suffer for others, not to care for others, or to do so begrudgingly, or only when there’s something in it for us. To make a donation, and then to spend twice as much publicizing the donation. To seek justice for a crime only when there’s a promise of a reward. These sorts of actions cannot be described as loving, except perhaps as self-loving.
So Jesus does not let the idea even enter his mind that he could get out of his responsibility and his duty and his mission, and live a different or more comfortable life. I know that Martin Scorsese has that film that explores this idea, of how Jesus experienced temptations such as this, and that's fine, that’s a piece of art, and a filmmaker's prerogative, to play with ideas about what it must have been like for Jesus to be tempted. But Jesus must reject it. He would be selling out his soul. We would sell out our souls if we didn’t hold to our responsibilities. Because temptations get to us as well, and we must not shirk our responsibilities to our neighbor, to the truth, to God.
We are called to be living sacrifices, as St. Paul says today (Rom 12). And there’s always a danger with living sacrifices, with people like Jeremiah, with Peter, with you and me. We are called to be sacrifices, but living sacrifices. Usually sacrifices placed on altars are killed, and so given to God. The trouble with living sacrifices is that they keep crawling off the altar. So Jeremiah tried to crawl off the altar, but in the end crawled back on.
And Peter, for his part, at the end of his life, a life full of proclaiming the Good News and teaching God’s ways and leading the church, he ends up in Rome, during the persecution of Christians, and he’s leaving Rome because of the persecutions, and he meets Jesus, or has a vision of Jesus on the road while leaving, and he asks Jesus “Where are you going?” And Jesus responds, “I’m going into the city, to be crucified again.” And Peter, understanding that this is his next and final participation in the willing sacrifice of Jesus, turns around, goes back to the city, and is ultimately arrested and he himself crucified, upside down.
We also suffer, we also are tempted. Let’s ask God for the strength to live our lives, our missions, as he teaches us and models for us, which is ultimately for our good, and for the good of all of his creation.