17/04/2024
How Come Jesus Died on Friday and Rose on Sunday? That's not Three Day and Nights.
Dear friend, the passage which seems to cause you doubt is found in the Gospel of Mt. 12:40: ***For just as Jonah was three days and three nights in the belly of the sea monster (whale), so for three days and three nights the Son of Man will be in the heart of the earth***.
If you take that scripture literally, Jesus was supposed to stay in the grave for 72 hours before rising to make it a complete three days and three nights but that does not seem to be what happened right?
If Jesus died on Friday by 3 pm and rose by the dawn of Sunday, it implies that He was only in the grave on Saturday alone for a complete day. By the conclusion of the 21st Century man, and as I have read the answers of many here on Quora, the conclusion would be that He couldn’t have died on Friday.
Many, here, posit that He could only have died on Wednesday so that He could have full Thursday, Friday and Saturday to be in the grave and then rise on Sunday. This is also not possible as it would only mean that Jesus rose, not on the third day as He has said but that He rose on the fourth day contrary to the Gospel account of the resurrection. That poses a fresh problem.
Before attempting an answer, let’s look at what scripture says:
***1Cor.15:4*** Apostle Paul wrote: ***… and that He was buried, and that He was raised on the third day in accordance with the Scriptures***.
Apart from ***Mt. 12:40*** the Evangelist later wrote: ***From then onwards, Jesus began to make it clear to His disciples that He was destined to go to Jerusalem and suffer grievously at the hands of the elders and chief priests and scribes and be put to death and be raised up ‘on the third day'***. So, how do we begin to explain ***Mt. 12:40***? Our first answer is that it is a figurative expression common with the Jews at the time. At that time, the phrase ***three days and three nights*** meant ***long enough time to be definitely dead. ***Here it was not meant to be a literal 72 hours.
In our day too, two phrases stands out. When we say a person ***takes eternity to solve a problem*** it does not mean eternity in the sense of forever but rather, it means an indefinite length of time. Also, a ***lifetime*** is similar to the above used to describe a situation that may never end or take a considerable amount of time rather than a time that will definitely never end.
When Jesus used it, the message He first wished to convey was that He would really die and not that He would be literally dead for 72 hours as modern people expect.
Now, the question is can we conclude from the Bible that Jesus spent three days in the tomb and rose on the third day?
The synoptic Gospels as well as the Johannine Gospel in their chronologies are unanimous in this – Jesus died on Friday and was buried, on the Saturday, He stayed dead in the grave/tomb and the tomb was found to be empty on Sunday. Let’s offer an explanation to this looking at the Bible.
1. Scripture says that Jesus died on ***the day of preparation*** and was buried the same day. So, which day is the ***day of preparation***? Certainly, not Wednesday as some people say. ***Mk. 15:42 ***and ***Lk. 23:54*** mentions it as the day before the Sabbath hence, the day of preparation is the day before the Sabbath.
***John 19:14*** places the Last Supper before the Passover Feast, while as well assigning the crucifixion to the ***day of preparation***.
The day of preparation is the Day before the Sabbath (Shabbat). It falls on Friday (note that the Jews did not name the week as we do today) *Shabbath* (Sabbath – Saturday or the seventh day) was the last day when God rested hence, the day before Saturday is Friday (Day of the Preparation).
Why was it called the day of the preparation?
**Reason**:
Remember that Jesus was accused of healing on the Sabbath Day? Why? The devout Jews were never permitted to do any servile work on the Sabbath. They would not even be expected to cook a meal so, they use the day before the Sabbath to do all the necessary preparations and arrangements, including cooking in anticipation of the Sabbath (please, read ***Exodus 16 ***for greater understanding of this concept).
In ***Exo16:23*** it is written: ***This is what the Lord has commanded: ‘tomorrow is a day of solemn rest, a holy Sabbath to the Lord, bake what you will bake and boil what you will boil, and all that is left over lay by to be kept till morning***. Since Sabbath was Saturday and Jesus died on the ***Preparation Day*** – a day to the Sabbath, He died on a Friday not a Wednesday. To conclude this, He died on Friday and was buried on Friday.
Furthermore, ***Lk. 23:56*** reads that as soon as Jesus was buried, the women ***returned and prepared spices and perfumed oils***. ***Then, they rested on the Sabbath according to the commandment***. Verse 54 gives us an insight into why Jesus was buried hurriedly, and the women returned quickly from the burial to prepare spices: ***It was the ******day of preparation*** (Friday), ***and the Sabbath was about to begin***. That means that they did the burial hurriedly so that the Sabbath will not catch up with them. Since they are not permitted to do anything servile on Sabbath (Saturday) they rushed home to prepare spices.
2. It must be noted that for the Jews, the day begins in the evening and ends on the following evening around 6pm. Friday evening was the beginning of the Sabbath day. Jesus was crucified at around 3pm on Friday but He was hurriedly buried and the women went home hurriedly to prepare spices before the Sabbath will catch up with them. They will not work all night as, we will do today, because that will already be the Sabbath Day. The Jewish Day start as around 6pm as against our present day system when the day begins at 12 am. How did we conjecture that? We can see that in the creation narrative in the Book of Genesis, the writer would say: ***there was evening, and there was morning – the first day*** ***(Gen.15)*** see also verses 8, 13, 19 etc. in our era it would have been ***there was morning and there was evening – the first day***.
What we have also to ask is
**What for the Jews is the first day of the week**?
The Gospels says succinctly that the tomb where Jesus was buried on the ***Day of Preparation (Friday) ***was found empty on The First Day of the Week (cf. ***Mt. 28:1***; ***Mk.16:1; Lk. 24:1; Jn.20:1***).
The Matthean text puts it this way: ***Now after the Sabbath, as the first day of the week began to dawn, Mary Magdalene and the other Mary came to see the tomb***.
The ***First Day of the Week*** is what we refer to as ***Sunday***.
**How do we conclude that it’s a Three Day**?
Since Jesus died on the ***Day of Preparation*** and the tomb was already empty on the ***First Day of the Week***, is it possible for us to say this is a ***Three Day ***period spent in the grave?
It sounds difficult and absurd for the modern readers of scripture because of our calendar system. Let’s explain this by an analogy. For us in the modern era, a child born in say June is a year older by the following year June. For instance, if Tom was born on the 23rd of June, 2023, he will only be a year old on the 23rd June, 2024 that is about twelve calendar months. For the Jew, if Tom was born on 23rd June 2023, if the year ends in December 2023, Tom is already a year old and by the 1st of January, he is already in his second year. The same principle apply to days. A child born at 3 pm on Friday is already a day old at 6pm of the same day since at that time another day has begun. The Jews counted part of a day as a whole day. To get the gist, let’s turn to the parable of the Land Owner which Jesus told ***(Mt.20:1-16)***. The Land Owner had agreed to pay the labourers a denarius for a full day’s work, he hired them at different times of the day 6am, 9am, 12pm, 3pm and 5pm but at the end of the day, He paid each of them a denarius each since they each have worked a full day even though they came at different times of the day.
When Jesus was crucified according to Luke’s narrative at around 3pm (cf. ***Lk.23:44-46***), it implies that the first day of His death was the remaining period of the Day 3pm to sundown (6pm).
The second day of His death began from sundown of Friday and lasted till sundown of Saturday thus He spent the whole day and night of Saturday in the tomb.
The third day began at sundown of Saturday and lasted until sunrise of the first Day of the week (Sunday).
**How did His Disciples interpret this?
**Scripture points out that on the way to Emmaus, on the Day of the Resurrection, His disciples said to Him ***It is now the third day since these things (death, burial and resurrection) happened*** ***(Lk24:21)*** thus indicating that they interpreted the days to be a three day period not four and not less than three. They did not count it in hours to be 72 hours but rather they counted it as days according to the Jewish understanding of the concept of days.