15/01/2020
I posted last year that we had obtained a blow for common sense when winning an appeal for a change of use of a large terraced property in Swansea to a HMO. Upset by the decision, Swansea Council made an application for judicial review of the decision on the basis that the Inspector had misinterpreted the relevant planning policy. I am pleased to report, however, that the judge refused the request for the review. He reasoned that in the circumstances of the case the Inspector could not have reached a different conclusion, regardless of the policy. I understand the wish of the Council to limit the number of new HMOs going forward but it is never right to dogmatically apply policy in every case regardless of the particular circumstances of that case.