10/14/2023
The situation in the Holy Land continues to weigh heavy on my heart. The United Church of Canada added it's voice to call for an immediate ceasefire - and condemns the killing of civilians. And I have been struggling with how to discuss the nuance of a very complicated context.
We cannot share news links on FB anymore, but I have cut and pasted the reflection of Haggai Matar, an award-winning Israeli journalist and political activist, and is the executive director of +972 Magazine (+972 is the country code used for dialing in Israel and Palestine). Thank you to the Planetary Resilience Council for sharing it with me. We know the death toll on both sides is now much higher, and both sides are committing horrific war crimes.
Her reflection was written in +972 Magazine in the first hours after the attacks on Israel broke out:
"This is a terrible day. After waking up to air sirens under a barrage of hundreds of rockets fired on Israeli cities, we have been learning about the unprecedented assault by Palestinian militants from Gaza into Israeli towns bordering the strip.
News is flowing in of at least 40 Israelis killed and hundreds wounded, as well as some reportedly kidnapped into Gaza. Meanwhile, the Israeli army has already begun its own offensive on the blockaded strip, with troops mobilizing along the fence and air strikes killing and wounding scores of Palestinians so far. The absolute dread of people who are seeing armed militants in their streets and homes, or the sight of fighter jets and approaching tanks, is unimaginable. Attacks on civilians are war crimes, and my heart goes to the victims and their families.
Contrary to what many Israelis are saying, and while the army was clearly caught completely off guard by this invasion, this is not a âunilateralâ or âunprovokedâ attack. The dread Israelis are feeling right now, myself included, is a sliver of what Palestinians have been feeling on a daily basis under the decades-long military regime in the West Bank, and under the siege and repeated assaults on Gaza. The responses we are hearing from many Israelis today â of people calling to âflatten Gaza,â that âthese are savages, not people you can negotiate with,â âthey are murdering whole families,â âthereâs no room to talk with these peopleâ â are exactly what I have heard occupied Palestinians say about Israelis countless times.
The attack this morning also has more recent contexts. One of them is the looming horizon of a normalization deal between Saudi Arabia and Israel. For years, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has been making the case that peace can be achieved without talking to Palestinians or making any concessions. The Abraham Accords have stripped Palestinians of one of their last bargaining chips and support bases: the solidarity of Arab governments, despite that solidarity having long been questionable. The high likelihood of losing perhaps the most important of those Arab states may well have helped push Hamas to the edge.
Meanwhile, commentators have been warning for weeks that recent escalations in the occupied West Bank are leading to dangerous paths. Throughout the past year, more Palestinians and Israelis have been killed than in any other year since the Second Intifada of the early 2000s. The Israeli army is routinely raiding into Palestinian cities and refugee camps. The far-right government is giving settlers an entirely free hand to set up new illegal outposts and launch pogroms on Palestinian towns and villages, with soldiers accompanying the settlers and killing or maiming Palestinians trying to defend their homes. Amid the high holidays, Jewish extremists are challenging the âstatus quoâ around the Temple Mount/Al-Aqsa Mosque in Jerusalem, backed by politicians who share their ideology.
In Gaza, meanwhile, the ongoing siege is continuously destroying the lives of over two million Palestinians, many of whom are living in extreme poverty, with little access to clean water and about four hours of electricity a day. This siege has no official endgame; even an Israeli State Comptroller report found that the government has never discussed long-term solutions to ending the blockade, nor seriously considered any alternatives to recurring rounds of war and death. It is literally the only option this government, and its predecessors, have on the table.
The only answers that consecutive Israeli governments have offered to the problem of Palestinian attacks from Gaza have been in the form of band aids: if they come from the ground, we will build a wall; if they come through tunnels, we will build an underground barrier; if they fire rockets, weâll set up interceptors; if they are killing some of ours, we will kill many more of them. And so it goes on and on.
All this is not to justify the killing of civilians â that is absolutely wrong. Rather, it is meant to remind us that there is a reason to everything that is happening today, and that â as in all previous rounds â there is no military solution to Israelâs problem with Gaza, nor to the resistance that naturally emerges as a response to violent apartheid.
In recent months, hundreds of thousands of Israelis have been marching for âdemocracy and equalityâ across the country, with many even saying they would refuse military service because of this governmentâs authoritarian trends. What those protestors and reserve soldiers need to understand â especially today, as many of them announced they will halt their protests and join the war with Gaza â is that Palestinians have been struggling for those same demands and more for decades, facing an Israel that to them is already, and has always been, completely authoritarian.
As I write these words, I am sitting at home in Tel Aviv, trying to figure out how to protect my family in a house with no shelter or safe room, following with growing panic the reports and rumors of horrible events taking place in the Israeli towns near Gaza which are under attack. I see people, some of them my friends, calling on social media to attack Gaza more fiercely than ever before. Some Israelis are saying that now is the time to eradicate Gaza entirely â essentially calling for genocide. Through all the explosions, the dread and the bloodshed, speaking about peaceful solutions seems like madness to them.
Yet I remember that everything that I am feeling now, which every Israeli must be sharing, has been the life experience of millions of Palestinians for far too long. The only solution, as it has always been, is to bring an end of apartheid, occupation, and siege, and promote a future based on justice and equality for all of us. It is not in spite of the horror that we have to change course â it is exactly because of it."
+972 Magazine is an independent, online, nonprofit magazine run by a group of Palestinian and Israeli journalists. Founded in 2010, their mission is to provide in-depth reporting, analysis, and opinions from the ground in Israel-Palestine.
(Photo: MS365 Stock image)
