08/19/2026
Let’s Make Sense of It: Equal Rights Don’t Take Anything Away
On August 18, 1920, Tennessee became the final state needed to approve the Nineteenth Amendment. That amendment said women could not be denied the right to vote because they were women.
Historian Heather Cox Richardson recently shared the history of that long fight. I want to credit her for the historical information that inspired this reflection.
What I keep thinking about is one simple question:
Why does giving someone an equal right make other people feel as if something has been taken from them?
Rights are not a pie. Giving another person a piece does not leave less for you.
A woman voting does not weaken a man’s vote. A Black person voting does not weaken a white person’s vote. A woman becoming a pastor does not take away a man’s calling.
Equality does not take away anyone’s rights. What it takes away is the idea that one group should always have more power than another.
Maybe that is what some people are afraid of.
The Nineteenth Amendment was an important victory, but it did not remove the barriers faced by every woman. Black women and many other women of colour were still prevented from voting through unfair laws, threats, and violence. It took another 45 years of struggle before the Voting Rights Act of 1965 provided stronger protection.
That law did not give people dignity. Their dignity was always there. The law forced the country to begin recognizing it.
I think about this when I look at women in ministry.
I have attended conferences where someone pointed to a panel of eight men and two women and said, “Look at our diversity!”
My first thought was: Seriously? We have to celebrate the fact that two women were allowed on the stage?
Even in churches that say women can be pastors, women are often guided toward children’s ministry or supporting roles. There is absolutely nothing lesser about children’s ministry. Helping shape the next generation is important and sacred work.
But here is my question: If that work is so valuable, why is it so often unpaid or underpaid?
Why is it frequently done by a volunteer or by the pastor’s wife, who may have just as much education and experience as her husband? Why does one ministry role receive a salary, authority, and recognition while another is treated as something women should simply do out of love?
I have also heard people argue that women are valuable because they give birth. Yes, women carry life, and that is powerful. But a woman’s value cannot depend on whether she becomes a mother.
Women deserve equal rights because women are human beings.
Today, some Christian nationalist pastors and thinkers are talking about replacing individual voting with one vote for each household. But who would cast that vote? The husband? The property owner? The so-called “head of the household”?
What happens when a husband and wife disagree? What happens to a single woman, a widow, or a woman trapped in an abusive marriage?
A family may share a home, but its members do not share one mind. Every adult has a conscience, a voice, and a life affected by the decisions of government.
No one should have to surrender that voice to someone else.
Sometimes people tell me they do not vote because they do not care enough to learn about the issues. That is hard for me to understand. Being able to walk away from voting is itself a privilege. It assumes the right will always be waiting when you decide you want it.
History tells us that rights can be denied. They can be weakened. They can be taken away when people stop paying attention.
So perhaps we need to ask ourselves some uncomfortable questions:
Why does equality feel threatening?
Why do we praise women for serving but resist letting them lead?
Why do we call women’s work valuable while refusing to pay them fairly?
And if someone were debating whether we deserved a voice, would we be comfortable staying silent?
These are not questions we should answer quickly. We need to sit with them. We need to learn, listen, vote, speak up, and peacefully protest when necessary.
Giving another person the same rights I have does not make me less free.
It simply makes us equal.
Historical background and inspiration: Heather Cox Richardson, “August 18, 2026.” The reflections and opinions expressed here are my own.
Today I’m sharing “I Am Woman” by Helen Reddy. It felt like the perfect song to go with this reflection.
As you read, perhaps it will remind you of a song, article, story, or personal experience. If it does, I would love to hear about it. Please share it in the comments so we can all listen, read, learn, and think together.
Rights are not pie. Giving someone else equality does not make the rest of us less equal.
Let’s make sense of it.
Go with God, and always be spicy.
Your incurably curious,
Rev P. D. Yetman
Helen Reddy "I Am Woman" official remastered 4K video from the albu...