23/10/2022
Reflection for the 30th Sunday in Ordinary Time
“Thank God I’m Better Than Others”
It is very easy for religious people to fall into a kind of self-righteousness. Their enthusiasm and generosity can plant the seeds of religious arrogance. They discover what commitment demands of them; they experience relative success in their endeavours to be faithful; they distance themselves from what they think might threaten their resolve; and then they pass judgment on those who do not share their values or experience their success. The growth of this kind of arrogance is often imperceptible, because there is enough truth in every step along the way that is difficult to recognize when one is veering off the track.
The fact is that some religious people are better than the rest of us. At issue is the reason WHY they might be better. The arrogant Pharisee clearly believed he was better because of what HE had done. He had been observant, and he was proud of it. The tax collector, on the other hand, was ashamed of what he had done. More to the point, he knew what God was able to do in the face of his sinfulness, and so he asked for mercy. Justification comes from God; it is not an equitable return for a job well done. The tax collector knew this, the Pharisee did not. The tax collector asked God for mercy, and he was granted his request. The Pharisee asked nothing of God, and so he received nothing.
There are various ways in which we show we are self-righteous, but basically, they show we have forgotten God is God and we are not. This is the attitude Jesus condemns. It presumes we are righteous in our own power, when it might be the case that we have not been thrown into a state of affairs that sorely tests the mettle of our virtue. It is one thing to be non-violent when the circumstances of life are relatively tranquil and quite another when one is immersed in brutal situations. Pregnancy means one thing to a woman who wants to bring a child into a stable and loving relationship and another to a frightened teenager. The observance of cultural mores, as important as they may be, do not justify a person. Only the goodness of God is.
When the circumstances of life support our efforts to be observant, we can easily assume a superior attitude toward those whose weaknesses are only too apparent. They may show failings in areas where we are resolute, but our disdain for them is a clear sign of both our ignorance of our human frailty and our lack of compassion for the frailty of others. Unfortunately, this attitude of arrogance can be brought to prayer by the pharisee in all of us.
- Dianne Bergant, with Richard Fragomeni
Preaching the New Lectionary-Year C
©2000, The Liturgical Press Collegeville, Minnesota