25/10/2026
Someone told me, “All Saints Day is Christian. Jesus owns 365 days a year, not 364.” He also claimed Halloween was a Christian tradition the world stole.
I agree every day belongs to Yehovah. But does that settle what He wants us to celebrate?
All Hallows' Eve is the vigil before All Saints' Day, a feast the Western Church established to honour departed saints and martyrs. Scripture tells us to remember faithful believers (Heb 13:7). But where are we told to establish a feast venerating departed saints or to seek their intercession? Scripture points us to Yeshua as our mediator (1 Tim 2:5). Yehovah also gave His own appointed times (Lev 23). It troubles me that His feasts are often dismissed while church traditions are defended.
And why 1 November? An earlier Roman commemoration was held in May. Later the feast was fixed on 1 November, alongside the much older Celtic festival of Samhain. Of all the dates available, that one? We cannot prove why, but knowing what some church leaders openly encouraged, I find the overlap hard to ignore.
In AD 601, Pope Gregory I instructed missionaries to turn pagan temples into churches and reshape pagan feasting into Christian celebrations. His letter survives, and it shows that such adaptation was encouraged.
At Sinai, Aaron built an altar before the golden calf and proclaimed, “Tomorrow will be a feast to Adonai” (Ex 32:5, TLV). He used Yehovah's name. Yet Yehovah condemned it. That was idolatry, and I am not saying handing out sweets is the same. But can we really miss the warning?
Yehovah warned against borrowing the nations' worship practices (Deut 12:30–31). Yeshua rebuked traditions that set aside God's commandments (Mark 7:6–13). Not every human tradition does that. But they make me examine what we bring into worship, however old the tradition.
Who gave the church authority to take existing religious practices, give them a Christian identity and assume Yehovah would accept them? That is the issue of syncretism I cannot ignore.