27/07/2026
After a deep study of Matthew 17 and 18, I’ve become convinced that there are leadership principles within these chapters that are rarely engaged in modern ministry. This article seeks to address that gap by presenting a different, though often unpopular, view of biblical leadership.
Authority in the church doesn't belong exclusively to leaders, it ultimately resides in the whole body and leadership exists to serve, (remember, He that is greatest among you is the servant of all), express and steward that shared authority, not replace it. Leaders are to read and understand what the Holy Spirit is doing/activating/speaking and demonstrating in the body and then articulate it to the church.
Leadership doesn’t replace the authority of the body. It serves it, expresses it, and stewards it.
Here’s the take based on Matthew 17:24 -27 and Matthew 18.
1) Leaders don’t “own” decisions, they discern with the body.
Instead of: “The pastor has decided so that's final.”
You get: Leaders listening, weighing and recognizing what God is doing among HIS people
Practical example:
Major direction (vision, discipline, doctrine) isn't imposed from the top down
Rather, it is tested, confirmed and recognized within the community
Leadership doesn't create authority they recognize it and articulate it.
I know of many visions rotting in paddocks because the Leadership had a "vision" yet the congregation, and by default the Spirit was never on board.
2) The congregation isn’t passive, it's responsible.
The same authority to bind and loose (permit/forbid, affirm/reject) that is given to Peter in Matthew 16 is bestowed upon the church in Matthew 18:18.
The people then:
Are not spectators
Are not just followers
But are participants in discernment and accountability
The implication is that:
Spiritual responsibility doesn't stop at leadership, the whole body carries weight in truth, correction and direction.
3) Church discipline is communal, not just leadership driven
In Matthew 18 the process moves:
a) Individual
b) Small group
c) Tell it to the church
Final authority rests in the assembled body, not just leaders. Restoration is not decided behind closed doors only. It is something the body recognizes and affirms together.
Why? Because it is the body that becomes desecrated by unchecked sin.
4) Leaders activate authority by alignment, not control
When leaders act rightly and are secure in Christ, they:
Bring clarity to what God is already doing
Give voice to what the Spirit is stirring in the body
Confirm what is true and just
Their authority is then not absolute, independent or detached it is representative and responsive.
5) It guards against 2 extremes
a) Authoritarian Leadership:
“Only leaders hear God” (control)
"Questioning leadership equals rebellion
b) Leaderless chaos
"Everyone just does what they feel" (the old God told me syndrome)
"No structure, no guidance"
Leaders are still essential, God operates within a structure
The balance:
The body holds authority.
Leaders steward and express it.
6) A healthy church looks like this:
– Leaders are trusted but not untouchable
– Members are engaged but not rebellious
– Decisions feel recognised, not forced
– Correction feels corporate, not political
- Unity comes from shared submission to Christ, not hierarchy alone
Here’s the reality:
Leadership doesn’t replace the voice of the body, it amplifies it.
They don’t possess authority instead of the church, they align with it and when they act rightly, they make visible what belongs to the whole.
When this breaks down:
Leadership becomes control.
The body becomes passive.
And the church stops functioning like a body at all.
This isn’t a critique without hope, it’s an invitation.
👉 To leaders: you don’t have to carry it all. When you align with the body, you step into a weight that heaven actually backs.
👉 To the church: your voice matters. Not in rebellion, but in responsibility, discernment, and truth.
If we return to this pattern, we don’t lose authority, we recover it.
And when the body and leadership come into true alignment under Christ, He doesn’t just observe the church, He stands in the midst of it and His church becomes an unstoppable force.