27/08/2026
Malvern Community,
Here’s a thought exercise:
Imagine you had to be tried in court for something serious, and the evidence was genuinely open to interpretation: would you rather your fate be decided by one judge or by a jury of twelve ordinary people?
For the moment ignore the circumstances and ponder the choice: judge or jury?
Perhaps you might prefer a judge, thinking "a qualified expert will see through emotion and get to the facts". You might want to ensure this is more important than persuasion, making sure the case decided on what is legally relevant, not on who presents better. A judge also understands evidence, legal standards and burden of proof better than ordinary people.
Or perhaps you might prefer a jury, thinking “I'd rather take my chances with ordinary people. I think I can get them to understand me”. You might have confidence in your ability to persuade. Also, the power is dispersed, and so with twelve people it’s harder for one prejudice, bad mood or personal theory to dominate.
I wonder what things might factor into your thinking?
Whether you trust competence more than people. Or the common-sense of people more than institutions. Or have previous experience with an authority figure. Or confidence in your own ability to persuade.
What would be your choice?
Nobody liked to be judged. But do you think truth is more likely to emerge through expert analysis, or through collective human judgment? Do you want to be judged ‘from above’ or ‘from alongside’?
Most people instinctively prefer a jury over a judge because they believe a group of regular citizens is fairer, more sympathetic, and less biased than one single official. Interestingly, however, a 2024 NSW study of more than 5,800 trials found that a judge-alone trials were associated with a higher acquittal rate.
This Sunday, as we continue our series on Identity, I want to ask a related question: who gets to decide who you are?
Because most of us spend a surprising amount of our lives before an imaginary jury, wondering what other people think of us, trying to explain ourselves, win approval, or persuade people that we are worthwhile. And sometimes the harshest judge of all is the one inside our own head.
But the New Testament offers a very different place to locate our identity. Paul writes:
“For you have died, and your life is hidden with Christ in God.” Colossians 3:3
That is a remarkable image. Your deepest identity is not up for a vote. It is not finally determined by the judgment of the crowd, the verdict of an authority figure, or even by your own assessment of yourself.
Your life is hidden with Christ in God.
What might it mean to live from an identity that secure?
Join us this Sunday 10am as I share on Resurrection Life from Colossians 2:20-23 and 3:1-4.
Tim