05/25/2026
Jon Noyes talks to an atheist and a Catholic at a women’s rights march about whether Jesus was an exclusivist, if all religions pray to the same God, and what grounds our values.
“Jesus says, ‘I’m the only way.‘ Right? ‘The only way to the Father is but by me.’ Muslims don’t teach that. Muslims teach that Jesus is a prophet who never died and therefore wasn’t raised. Jews teach that Jesus was a false prophet who died and was buried and stayed dead. So, all three of those things can’t be true at the same time.”
“The people I’m speaking with, they argue that all religions are just different paths up the same mountain, but that’s simply just not true, because it’s not possible.”
“When people say faith is believing without evidence, that’s not Christianity. That’s a caricature of what Christianity is. Faith isn’t a blind leap. It’s reasonable trust based on what God has already done.”
Find the full video and transcript in the comments.
