28/01/2026
Contra naturam, non legislat
Contra naturam non legislat
(You can't legislate against nature)
We recognize the importance of the gift of celibacy; however, the truth is: it is NOT for everyone.
It is a special gift separate from the gift of the priesthood. The discipline of celibacy is not inherent to the priesthood, nor does it align with tradition and scripture. That is why celibacy was not present from the very start of the Church, but developed later and was institutionalized mainly to protect and preserve Church property.
Historically, celibacy in the Catholic Church emerged as an early tradition in the 4th century, but became a mandatory, enforced discipline in the Western Church only during the 12th-century reforms of Pope Gregory VII and the Lateran Councils. The Council of Elvira (c. 305) first mandated sexual continence, while the First (1123) and Second (1139) Lateran Councils formally made celibacy obligatory for priests.
Celibacy should be highly esteemed and encouraged—but it should not be compulsory. When it is forced, individuals may lose the freedom to make choices as their life situations change.
Celibacy has led many priests to commit mortal sin, leaving them unable to serve in a state of grace. Worse still, as stated in the messages of Our Lady of Fatima: "Many souls are now in hell because of the sins of the flesh"—and many priests have fallen into this situation.
Sadly, this discipline has also taken a heavy toll on priestly vocations. Data covering the four decades after the Second Vatican Council (1964–2004) estimates that 69,000 to nearly 100,000 Catholic priests left active ministry. This figure is now 20 years old and does not include those who have left in the intervening years.
So, does mandatory celibacy truly serve the Church well—or does it harm her instead?